Idol Thoughts: On Perfume, Homophobia, and the Reactions

The one week I had a lot of ideas in mind for what I wanted to write, and I got asked to write a blog post on the Perfume scandal (of sorts).

First, let me just say that while Perfume isn’t a group I talk about a lot, I do like them. While I don’t follow them as much as I used to, I enjoyed the group a lot in early 2010. In fact, the reason for the Disco in Happy Disco is because of Chocolate Disco and (mostly) One Room Disco. In fact, I’d consider One Room Disco to be one of my favorite PVs and a favorite song of mine.

If you haven’t heard, there’s been a bit of fuss online over statements made by Perfume in an interview. The biggest article (that got people talking) was the one on aramatheydidnt. This took  snippets from a longer interview that was originally published in English. 

Copy-pasting the section in question from the longer interview:

Earlier this year, the trio embarked on a world tour, covering the U.K., France, and Germany (Read: J-Pop Sensation Perfume Takes Paris by Storm). For Japanese pop acts used to polite crowds who listen attentively, the crowd’s reaction in other countries came as something of a surprise to Perfume. “In Japan, we usually would start hearing people shout right before the performance, but in the U.K., people started shouting out passionately, ‘Per-fu-me!’ while clapping forty minutes before the show started, as if it were a soccer game!” says A-Chan.

“Also, when we met about ten fans from each country at the autograph sessions, there was a person who had ‘Perfume’ tattooed on his wrist. That was pretty shocking. He had tattoos on all sorts of places. I asked him, ‘didn’t it hurt to get a tattoo there?’ and he replied, ‘not really,’ then he started taking his pants off and we were like, ‘what is he going to do?’”

“He had another tattoo that said, ‘Love the World,’ which is an album that we released worldwide. He seemed so proud of it. I don’t have any tattoos so I’m not sure how deep a love that signifies, but I think it’s pretty incredible. And there were people who made gifts for us — tissue cases made from Japanese paper, for example. One particular fan said, ‘a Japanese friend gave it to me, but I want you to have it.’ I was like, ‘isn’t it a reverse import!?’ I can buy something like that anytime, but I guess for that person it was something very special. I answered a bit awkwardly, ‘tha…thank you,’” says A-Chan.

The group also discovered that their fan base demographic in European countries was somewhat different to Japan, where the ratio of male and female fans is almost equal. “Overseas, there were more men than women, and also people who were neither!” says A-Chan. “A gay couple came to our singing session and one of the guys introduced to us his ‘girlfriend.’ But the guy gave me a huge rose saying, ‘I love you so much! ­– I also love him (a guy), which means I like guys, but because I love you so much he doesn’t believe I like guys! Tell him something to convince him that I like guys!’ and I was like, ‘what in the world am I supposed to say to that!’ A lot of extraordinary things happened.”

First off, the thing I find very rude that hasn’t gotten a lot of discussion was what A-Chan said about the fan who gave her that gift from Japan. It actually shocks me to read this. Not to say that Perfume and other acts might not think that certain gifts are strange, but I assumed that music acts, especially ones with such longevity and media appearance as Perfume, would have enough tact to not single one fan’s gift out for being odd. It made her seem a bit ungrateful, which put me off.

Secondly, there are two sections in question: the “Men, women, and neither” statement and the meeting with the gay couple.

First off, the “men, women, neither” statement. Brian of Idolminded posted a link to the Perfume City forums where they discuss this in greater depth which educated me, as a casual Perfume fan. Essentially, A-chan uses this at Perfume concerts, emulating another singer who did so first, and it does reach out to the gay fans. Some foreign fans have speculated it’s reaching out to genderqueer fans, fans who don’t identify with a gender, but I think this is giving Perfume a bit too much credit in terms of gender representation. Most Western countries have enough of a hard time thinking outside the concept of a gender binary, and gender is behind a lot of these countries in terms of LGBT rights and representation. So I do think it’s referring to the gay fans, especially given the juxtaposition in this article, and what I’ve read on it on Perfume City leads me to the same conclusion.

Sexual orientation and gender identity have absolutely nothing to do with one another. So, even with the background and the rationale for saying this, it does make A-chan sound fairly ignorant. That said, I don’t think she was intentionally ignorant or trying to be intentionally malicious with her statements; it’s just something reinforced by the culture in which she was raised, and she frankly might think what she’s doing is fine, especially if LGBT fans of Perfume rally around that. This doesn’t necessarily make it OK and perfect; I have a lot of issues with Japanese culture (mostly around feminism and LGBT rights) and this just shows an aspect of the culture I’m not fond of.

Some fans are getting a bit defensive, so there’s one thing I’ll want to say about this: to be homophobic, you don’t have to be doing it consciously or intentionally. In fact, I’d say one of the worst kinds of homophobia, misogyny, etc. is the unintentional kind, because it both reflects and reinforces negative aspects of the overall culture.

As for the second issue, the fans, I’d say the worst part of the whole thing was the use of the word “girlfriend.” However, without context, it’s difficult to know what happened. Did the man introduce the person as his “girlfriend” or was that something A-chan put in? Did A-chan specifically use the word “girlfriend” or did she use “koibito” (non-gender specific word for ‘lover’) and it got translated funny? It’s hard to know, really, what went down. Personally I don’t blame her for being awkward because that fan did put her in a strange spot, trying to somehow prove his sexuality. I don’t know if A-chan necessarily needed to mention it, but I don’t think she was at fault here.

So ultimately, is Perfume a giant group of homophobic people? Nah, not really. I mean, they could probably use more coaching on how to approach the press, but there seems to be zero malicious intent and some ignorance that stems from the culture.

That said, the one thing I don’t really like is how people have been reacting to this. The almost overwhelming response has been people saying the initial arama poster was overreacting, getting defensive over Perfume, and being kind of angry.

First off, everyone’s entitled to their own opinion, and they’re allowed to support whatever they want. Some people have called to boycotting Perfume, and they’re in their right to do so. If you’re not offended, good for you. People are allowed to be offended at things, and stop supporting a group for whatever reason they want. I stopped watching the show Glee because of a rape joke that just made me quit the show entirely. Some people might think that’s extreme, but it’s my prerogative. Just because you’re not offended doesn’t mean people aren’t offended. And that goes both ways.

It’s also OK to criticize things you like and still like them. A blog post I posted around the time of the Miichan scandal comes to mind. If this bugs you and you still want to like Perfume, that’s absolutely fine. It’s OK to be critical of things you enjoy. I’m a big fan of the show Once Upon a Time, but I wish there were more characters on the show that weren’t white. It’s not a terrible thing to disagree with something and continue to like that thing.

That said, I think that for a lot of people this is bringing up the issue of how to view another culture entirely. I’m not saying everyone in Japan is regressive in terms of gender and sexuality, but the track record for LGBT rights in Japan isn’t great. Which goes along with that blog post I linked; it’s OK to like things from a cultural perspective you may disagree with. I personally wish that Japan would end up being more progressive, but I still listen to way too much idol pop and follow the music industry. I do think that people should be aware of these things, though. I think it’s easy as a Westerner to become enamored with places like Japan; it’s a very different culture with a very different history, but it’s still modern and industrialized. I think it’s important to be aware of the issues within a culture, so that there isn’t a blind adoration of an interesting but flawed society. I’m not saying America’s perfect; goodness knows that there are a LOT of things I would change about American society and culture. However, no country is perfect, and I think it’s important to keep that in mind.

So while I don’t come out of this hating Perfume or hating Japanese culture, I do hope that this might bring around some awareness. Unfortunately, since so many people disagree with the idea of these statements being homophobic, I could see a lot of people rejecting this altogether. So I can only hope this is an educational experience as much as it’s able, and that it causes people to think.

What do you think about the situation? Leave a comment and I’ll reply to you in next week’s Your Thoughts post!

Your Thoughts: Bias and Blogging

This week’s comment came from BeForJess of Happy Go Lucky! Thanks for commenting again!

It’s nice to see articles like this that illuminate facets of the idol blogging world!

I’ll be totally honest – it actually confuses me that so many people feel the need to preface their blogs with statements about how it’s their opinion… Simply because I feel like that’s the very essence of a blog. To get your opinions out there.

What a boring blogging world we’d have if nobody spoke opinion and talked about the things they are biased towards or against. Some of the best idol blogs out there are ones where I don’t even agree with the writer’s opinion nine times out of ten… But I like to see someone else’s perspective.

Generally speaking, the furthest I’ll ever go is to preface something particularly polarizing with a phrase like, “in my opinion”, or something similar. For all the high praise and low blows I’ve dished out on my blog, I haven’t really dealt with anything in the way of backlash. I’m not too worried about my biases showing and affecting others either – in fact, if my love for someone can influence someone else to love that idol too, all the better. Even with a negative bias, it can be comforting to know that even though the whole world loves idol X, you can’t stand her and you’re not alone.

As far as Happy Disco goes – I think you do just fine! Don’t move towards censoring your opinions to cover your bias, because you have your bias for a reason, and if you share your love, you might convince someone else to give them a try too. :)

I agree with what you said. I do think it would be boring if bloggers were expected to be completely unbiased and not share what they like and dislike. I mean, that’s the point of a lot of blogs. I also agree that I like reading opinions different to mine. I enjoy a wide variety of discourse, because that helps inform my own ideas and opinions.

As for prefacing blog posts, I generally tend to use language like “in my opinion” and “I think” just to erase all doubts that Happy Disco is just Serenyty’s realm of idol thoughts. I do wish it was less necessary to say something, but people can get a bit defensive of their favorites. I know that Chiima of Okay! Musume Time, for example, got some flack for writing critical things of Berryz Koubou. I’m not saying you have to agree with everything I write, but I would like to avoid internet rage (until I start reviewing video games or something like that). But I do try to share my feelings in general, even if I err on the side of caution.

The one statement that really resonated with me for this is “you have your bias for a reason.” Because that’s true; bloggers so often go to defend themselves with saying “I have a bias for this” when really, that’s just a personal taste that informs your opinions. I have a bias towards Team Syachihoko, but that’s because of the group, not because I have a bias there.

Thank you for your excellent comment, I appreciate it!

Idolminded’s Ray wrote a fairly long response to my last post on the Rec Reading post, so I decided to post that here too! (I know I get a lot of my views from Idolminded, but if you don’t visit Idolminded you absolutely should. I write there too!).

For a while, I’ve noticed a lot of younger bloggers seem more self-aware and pro-active about making sure their opinions are taken as opinions, a fear of backlash if that was not clear enough. I come from a pre-Internet tradition of pop-culture journalism, and so I always assumed my readership knew where I stood and that my writing would reinforce that stance. I wonder if this current self-awareness about biases and opinions is something that comes with growing up in the Internet age, where flame wars and willful misunderstanding of authorial intent is so common.

All that said, I have a general disdain for the notion of an absolute objective journalism. The idea that all opinions are equally valid is intellectually dishonest: some people are better informed, have thought out issues more, and are more articulate than others. Those opinions should be valued more than unreflective, off-the-cuff controversy-mongering. (And historically speaking, the notion of journalistic objectivity was not an attempt to provide better news but to sell papers to a wider audience – playing both sides of the fence, as it were.)

There is a great tradition of partisan and advocacy journalism, and I believe one can write in such a manner that one’s biases are understood to be in the service of honest intellectual inquiry. There’s a difference between trying to make people believe your opinions are the only right ones, and using your opinions as a starting point for a more extensive discussion. If you write as if you’re trying to win a shouting argument, you’re probably doing it wrong.

What matters is not objectivity: what matters is awareness of one’s biases, an innate respect for other people’s opinions (there’s a huge difference between respecting opinions and saying they’re equal), and a natural curiosity willing to test one’s values (and those of others) in the quest for greater enlightenment. Which may all sound kind of lofty, but in today’s media maybe we need such reminders once in a while

I honestly don’t have much to add, because I really like what was written and I want everyone to read it. However, I do have to say that as a somewhat younger blogger, I do think growing up online has a part of why I have to think about this. I was born in 1991 and I can’t even remember not having internet (since my dad’s pretty tech savvy). I spent a lot of my teen years involved on forums and in fan communities, and I’ve seen lots of anger and rage over fairly benign/pointless opinions. This has caused me to be slightly defensive in my writing style, I think mostly because of the nature of the internet and its instantaneous feedback. I haven’t had too much issues with Happy Disco and being an idol fan as a whole, but experiences of mine have informed how I write, for better or worse.

I do think there is a place for objective journalism, but I don’t think it’s somehow more valid than biased journalism, nor is it easy to achieve. While journalism/news wasn’t a major facet of my undergraduate education in media studies, there was one section in my Television-centered class on televised news. We analyzed news clips from American news outlets like CNN, and even if they’re trying to be unbiased in wording and opinion, there’s still a matter of what you present, how you present it. For example, American news media generally ignores stories that don’t have as much of a visual content, or stories that are ongoing (i.e. not “breaking news”). Because really, most news networks need viewers more than anything. When I studied abroad in the UK, it was refreshing to watch BBC news because the lack of commercials means that they aren’t focusing on ad financing. Since the BBC has always had education as a core focus, this improves their news quality.

That said, I absolutely agree that not every issue has equally correct people on both sides. Just because an issue has two sides doesn’t mean that both are right and that both are equally valid. Perhaps objectivity isn’t the correct word, and honesty is? I think that there’s a lot of good in sharing your opinions, but at the end of the day I still want journalism to attempt honest reporting.

The last paragraph is my favorite, though, and I absolutely agree.

Idol Thoughts: Bias and Blogging

This week, I became aware of a post on the blog Momo-Musu about bias and idol fandom. It’s an interesting thing to think about, and one I know I’ve encountered in my own fandom. Sometimes I wonder if my own prejudices get in the way of enjoying some things.

But in any case, that’s not what I’ve come to talk about. The thing that this post has started making me think about is how biases directly and indirectly affect my own blog and reviews as a whole.

I am a biased person. Really, we all are. Everyone has their own likes and dislikes, even if some are founded in reasonable things. Personally, I have a lot of groups I favor (Team Syachihoko being the most notable) and and styles of music I like more than others. For example, I generally like upbeat and fast-paced songs over a slower ballad. This doesn’t mean I will always hate a ballad, but that I will more likely prefer an average fast-paced song over the average ballad.

But, while having biases is generally understood and accepted, people who blog and do reviews are in an interesting position. It doesn’t take much to be a blogger; when I started Happy Disco I just spent about ten minutes setting up a blogspot blog. There’s very little barrier of entry. But doing so sets up your opinions to be read, discussed, and disagreed with.

I honestly have difficulty deciding how objective I should be while writing Happy Disco, especially in doing reviews and my TIF segments. How objective should I be in reviewing something? Do I need to only look at it in the most objective terms possible or can I put my own biases into the review? Personally, I try to be fair even with things that I might not like, but I don’t have many qualms with saying I prefer something to something else. However, this would be a lot different, if I had Happy Disco set up differently. Since I formed the blog, I’ve made it clear that this is my personal space for my thoughts on idols, which include reviews and commentary.

The biggest thing I wonder is how apparent should I make my biases. A lot of people get sent over to my blog via search engines or by referral from blogrolls and Idolminded posts. Some posts get read more than others. Should I put a big disclaimer over everything, stating all my likes and dislikes and how they might influence me? I should hope that I don’t need something like this, but the reality is that not everyone is going to be a loyal Happy Disco reader; most people find my site because they’re looking up a group.

I also wonder about my language while writing reviews. I usually try to make things clear that I’m just saying my own personal opinion and not stating fact. However, that isn’t always clear to everyone, and I know that back in school I was encouraged to stop using phrases like “I think” in my writing to avoid weak writing and sounding wishy-washy. It’s a difficult thing to balance, especially since I’m trying to make my writing more professional in hopes of someday figuring out a paying gig for my writing.

Ultimately, I’m pretty comfortable with where I’m at right now. I try to make it clear that Happy Disco is a one-woman project and that everything on this blog is my own opinion. I aim for some objectivity, and I try to say if someone else might something better than me. It’s just a difficult situation.

If you blog, what do you try to do? Do you like how I approach this on Happy Disco, or would you prefer I do something else? Let me know your thoughts and you’ll end up in my Your Thoughts post for next week!

Your Thoughts: Girls Generation vs. America

Happy Wednesday! I got one new reply today, and that’s from Nikki! Quick plug: she does a cosplay idol group called SBA0048; they do AKB0048 cosplay and cover AKB songs! So check them out!

I don’t know – they have a better chance than the four who have really made the (half-assed, let’s be honest) attempt to break out on US soil: Wonder Girls, Utada, BoA, and that one guy who was in KAT-TUN a long time ago. Jin? I don’t know. I’m not a boy band type.

In all three cases there was little to no promotion, little to no radio airplay, and the sheer fact that they were *gasp* ASIAN with *gasp* ACCENTS made it difficult for casual listeners to get into it.

Honestly I think the group with the best chance is 2ne1 – three out of four members speak fluent, accentless english, their music style is one that is really popular here anyway, and they’re trendsetters in fashion circles already. The will.i.am connection doesn’t hurt either.

That said, I think you’re right: ANY effort coming out of any other place, whether it’s European, Asian, African, South American, whatever, has to be concentrated in the US for at least a year. And it has to be a massive effort – the resources of whatever agency have to be concentrated on that for the entire promotional period. It won’t work otherwise. Whoever it is has to become a household name, has to be familiar to the average tween, teen, early twenty-something american person, or else it’ll remain a niche thing. And there has to be fairly regular releases even after the intense promotional period, or people will get bored with the lack of new stuff. Americans, as a whole, are really impatient.

Anyway that’s my long diatribe about potential Asian success in America – it’s a subject I’ve thought about often. Mostly because I want to see the groups I like live without having to fly my ass to Japan.

First off, Girls Generation definitely has the best chance out of the ones who’ve tried so far. However, how much of that is due to the fact they haven’t REALLY tried yet? I mean, there was a ton of hype around Wonder Girls when they first came to the US. They were opening for the Jonas Brothers (ah, remember when those guys were relevant?) and selling copies of their CDs in the US. Even though the only place I physically saw the CDs was in a tween clothing store where I was applying for a part-time job. And the CDs looked cheap. But in terms of popularity, Girls’ Generation has a pretty solid American fanbase already, and probably do have the best chance out of all the Asian music acts.

I agree about 2NE1, though. Their partnership with will.i.am ensures that there will be some mainstream appeal. I know a lot of people rag on the Black Eyed Peas, but their music is EVERYWHERE. If will.i.am can sufficiently promote 2NE1 and get them some radio time, they could be pretty big. The English speaking nature certainly helps, too. I know that two Girls Generation members speak English, but it feels a bit awkward having the two of them doing all the talking.

As for style though,  I’m not quite sure. Conventional wisdom is that American fans want cooler, edgier music and style. However, look at stuff like Blurred Lines. That was the most popular song of the year and, stylistically, it was probably closer to AKB48’s Koisuru Fortune Cookie than a lot of the KPop music out there. I think the biggest thing is getting a catchy song at the right time.

I do agree about promotion. I think the biggest thing that acts do wrong when trying to break into the US market is think that doing just a couple promotional things is OK. An opening act here, a tv appearance there. They have to do something big and keep going with it.

But yeah, I basically agree with your comment, and I agree with your final sentiment. I’d like more acts to come this way, too, so I hope that more groups think about how they promote themselves more carefully!

Idol Thoughts: Girls Generation vs. America

Serenyty’s talking about KPop? This is Hallyu Disco level nonsense!

But seriously, Kpop. I write about Japanese music, but it’s hard to argue that KPop is becoming a bigger force in the US than JPop. Even though AKB48 is what makes it in Wreck-It Ralph, Perfume have shown up multiple places, and Kyary Pamyu Pamyu got a viral hit with Pon Pon Pon, 2NE1 is being produced by will.i.am of the Black Eyed Peas, Girls’ Generation is performing on American TV, and Psy has kind of the biggest video ever with Gangnam Style. KPop is getting kind of big, where Jpop is still a niche interest in the US.

This past week, Girls Generation had another American success. This was the first ever YouTube Music Awards, and Girls’ Generation won the award for Video of the Year, even with competition like Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga and Miley Cyrus.

I have to say, seeing Tiffany on the same stage as Comedian/Musician Reggie Watts is kind of the weirdest thing, as a side note.

But anyways, Girls’ Generation took home this honor for their video for ‘I Got a Boy,’ and won this from fan activity on the YouTube videos. And really, KPop is great at one thing, and that’s fan activity. As Tao Jones of the Wall Street Journal put it, “These awards measure one thing, and one thing only — the obsessive, insatiable, all-consuming devotion of the musicians’ fan bases.
And in that aspect, K-Pop fans stand head, shoulders and starry eyes above the milling crowd as the most dedicated congregation of idol-worshippers in the pop culture universe — bar none.”
And while I don’t know if I’d necessarily agree with that completely; idol wota might give KPop idol fans a run for their money, KPop fans are nothing if not enthusiastic and dedicated, as marked by this win.

Personally, while I like this video, I don’t think it’s Girls’ Generation’s best song or video. Nevertheless, this post isn’t about the actual content, it’s about what this means for KPop and Asian pop music as a whole in regards to the American music industry. Will this win change anything?

Probably not. “A peak of more than 220,000 people were concurrently live-streaming the event.” This wasn’t very well watched, and I’m sure that GG’s unusual win will blow over soon.

Still, it’s one of the many ways that Kpop has kind of flirted with the idea of becoming A Thing in the US market, and never quite really making it. Why is this the case?

1. Racism. It’s a bit of an uncomfortable subject, but I still see a good deal of racism coming from reactions to GG. Sure, it’s mostly upset fans whose favorite artist didn’t win, but it’s still present.

2. Groups who don’t speak English have it tougher. Quick, name a popular music group/artist in the US that isn’t a native English speaker OR a native Spanish speaker. I know I can’t think of much. Even though two members of Girls’ Generation were born in the US and speak fluent English, it still seems daunting for a lot of people to listen to music they don’t understand, never mind that Girls’ Generation would probably put out stuff in English, like they did with The Boys.

3. Attention is divided between countries. Girls’ Generation is really big in South Korea, Japan, and they’re on the verge in the US. For nine girls, they’re getting spread a bit thin, promoting in all three countries. I honestly have trouble thinking that a group could promote a bit in the US, disappear for a while, and expect to come back. No KPop (or Jpop artist, for that matter) really seems to fully commit to promoting themselves in the US, which I think is their biggest issue.

Ultimately, what does an Asian pop group really need to succeed in the US? A really catchy song that gets on the radio, without gimmicks. PSY may have hit it big with Gangnam Style, but the impression most people have is from the music video. Even if they think the song is catchy or good, and it got some radio time, it still feels like it’s more of a novelty than anything. Even when he started putting up followup songs, people are always going to remember him as that guy who did Gangnam Style. But even one song could turn it around for a KPop group, if they could really promote it fully (not just selling their CD in tween clothing stores).

And honestly, I think as soon as the US opens up to KPop, that might be the chance for a JPop group to try and do the same thing. While I almost exclusively follow JPop, I’d argue that most music fans wouldn’t necessarily go “oh, this is Japanese not Korean, I can’t touch this.” But once the US starts accepting music from places like South Korea, music from Japan could be an option.

What do you think? Do you think that this YouTube Music Award win could mean big things for Girls’ Generation? Do you think Girls’ Generation has a chance in the US? Does any Asian pop act? Leave a comment below and you could be a part of next week’s Your Thoughts post!

Your Thoughts: Evolving Groups

I got two wonderful responses for my last Idol Thoughts post, so let’s get right to them!

First comes from Skoban of Ice Cream & My Jiggly (I appreciate the v-u-den reference, by the way!) “There’s also another perspective you might be missing out on – that as idol observers, we’ve evolved as well.
For example, there are times when I listen to an idol’s back catalogue, and a song I dismissed as lame initially sounds amazing to me now. And that’s a perspective change from my point of view – the song itself hasn’t changed.
Just like an idol group can’t get rid of their past, neither can we discard the experiences that shape the us of now. All we can do is embrace what has passed.

Also, I think it’s okay to stop liking a group, to admit that the idols you like have changed and that you may not agree with the direction they’re going through.
There is the trap of being locked in nostalgia, to limit oneself to only old releases (e.g. 4-nin S/mileage forever!), but that’s a very limiting stance in my opinion.
Happily, we’re now in a period where we’re spoilt for choice, and if someone doesn’t like the direction one group is heading in, there’s probably some other group out there more to their liking.

First off, thank you SO much for bringing this up. This is something really important that I just happened to forget about. Sometimes people change, which makes your perspective change. I’m sure this has happened to pretty much everyone. Sometimes you might want to hold onto old favorites; the idol fandom isn’t necessarily the best about embracing oshihenning, for example. But as people change, so do their experiences, and that impacts how they view and interact with art/music.

I also very much agree with the last statement. Back in late 2008 and early 2009, when I was still a new idol fan, there was Hello!Project and AKB, but neither were all that big. There wasn’t much else if you didn’t care much for either. Today, there are so many idol groups, that if one doesn’t make you happy there is another to interest you. Once I stopped paying as much attention to MomoClo, I found Team Syachihoko and Dempagumi.inc. We are in a period where there is a huge abundance of idol groups, and we should enjoy that.

Thank you for your insightful comment, Skoban! I appreciate it!

The last comment comes from BeForJess from Happy! Go! Lucky!: One thing that I will say about Momoclo is that while their indie stuff like Momoiro Punch and Mirai e Susume is miles away from stuff like Neo Stargate and GOUNN, at the same time I feel like their major debut stuff, like Ikuze and Pinky Jones do have ties to some of their latest stuff. The insanity of Ikuze was there in Moretsu and Otome Sensou, and the weird cultural themes and music that were in Pinky Jones are in GOUNN (not the same ones, but you know). But there’s no denying that they have certainly grown in different directions than they seemed to be going in the beginning.

I’m a little half and half because I really do miss that good old fashioned idol-cute-fun-happy vibe from stuff like Hashire and Orange Note, but at the same time I love being blown away by the new and different things they experiment with in their new stuff. If we could just get a mix of the two it would be perfect for me.

Personally, while I would agree that there are connections between Ikuze/Pinky Jones and the current stuff, I do think there’s a difference. Perhaps it’s mostly just me, but the energy level between Ikuze and GOUNN has changed a lot. The cultural themes between Pinky and GOUNN does draw an interesting comparison, though.

I personally appreciate some of the things they’re doing, but they don’t grab me the way they used to. I agree, though; if there was a mix of the older stuff and the newer stuff, I would be a lot happier.

Thank you for your comment as well!

Idol Thoughts: Evolving Groups

Recently, reviewing Momoiro Clover Z’s GOUNN has made me nostalgic. So I’ve watched some of the older Momoiro Clover PVs, thinking about how much the group has changed.

The group is nearly unrecognizable. And I apologize in my reviews of MomoClo if I sound at all bitter, but it’s hard sometimes to reconcile the current group with the past group.

A group’s evolution is something every idol fan has to go through, really, unless the group is very shortlived. This hit close to home with how much Momoiro Clover has changed, but, for example, look at how vastly Morning Musume has changed over the years since the group has formed. The group that put out Wagamama Ki no Mama Ai no Joke bears no resemblance to the group that put out Ai no Tane. I don’t feel comfortable saying “I’m a Morning Musume fan;” instead it would be a lot more accurate to say “I’m a 1997-2005 and a 2012 – current Morning Musume fan.”

This has happened with other groups as well; I know people who have gotten tired of AKB because favorite members have left, or because they aren’t doing anything as risky as Keibetsu Shiteita Aijou or Seifuku ga Jama wo Suru anymore.

This is a tough thing to think about, I think partially because you become so invested in idol groups. Idol groups are centered around the concept of support, that you should support the groups you love, but what if a group becomes something you don’t want to support?

This isn’t just an idol thing. For a while I was a very big Doctor Who fan. I love the seasons with Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant. Then Steven Moffat took control of the show and it was just disappointing. Here was a show I adored, but was going in directions I just didn’t like. I haven’t watched the show since about the middle of the 6th series, and it still bums me out. I also really liked Glee for a while, but then its quality got so bad that it was not the show I got into.

It’s kind of hard not to sound bitter, and like I’m not someone who’s ranting completely. I even like a lot of the things that current MomoClo has done. If the current MomoClo was a completely different group from the MomoClo I became a fan of, then I would probably welcome this group with open arms. But that’s not the case.

I’m sorry to sound unhappy on a blog called Happy Disco. I’m honestly really happy with the idol industry right now, and there are tons of groups that I think are doing great things. But it’s just hard as a fan to go through some of these changes.

Your Thoughts: Do Idols Need Talent?

This week I got a lovely comment from one of my favorite idol bloggers and a friend of mine, Chiima of Okay! Musume Time!

Much like you, I feel that Sasshi is right in one way, but wrong in another. Idols don’t necessarily need that talent, but they need a likeability factor about them, and for some, their likeability factor is their skills in dancing, singing, or how they portray themselves. Nakanishi Kana, for example, has the skill of being able to speak. She speaks very well (which surprised me, because I always took her as the goofy girl I loved and cherished) and, whilst it doesn’t seem like a talent, has become one of her strong points, as Yattaruchan has shown (and Hello! Pro Station when she MC’ed). But some girls do need their talent to get them by, like Maeda Atsuko. I find Acchan so boring and bland, and she is forgettable with her looks, but her voice is so pretty to listen to.

For me though, I like Idols for various reasons, whether it is their talent (Ayumi as a dancer), their looks (Iikubo Haruna) or just because I absolutely adore them for their lack of talent and other driving factors about them which make them shine in my eyes (Eripon and her awkward beauty, her love for Gaki etc, and Niigaki Risa for her acting skills).

But like you say in your post, it is how the Idol is marketed, and when marketed well, they can truly shine as Idols and prove their worth in different areas that do not focus on singing or dancing.

By the way, very well written, and a joy to read. I love you~

This is pretty much what I think. Standing out is pretty much the biggest thing an idol needs to do. At this point, there are hundreds and hundreds of idols in Japan. The 48 groups alone have hundreds of members, and there are even more groups out there. If you’re going to be an idol, it’s important, if you want fans, to have something that they can latch onto. The reason I became a fan of Team Syachihoko’s Ooguro Yuzuki, for example, is her obvious enthusiasm while performing. Other idols have similar qualities, but just the level of her excitement is really special.

Chiima brings up an interesting point with Maeda Atsuko, though. I’d consider her to be one of the most important, popular idols of all time. Yet, there’s nothing about her that really stands out. She does have a pretty voice, but there are stronger vocalists out there. She’s pretty, but not particularly gorgeous. She doesn’t have a big personality, or something that really stands out. Yet she was very popular. A good part of this is the push, since she was pushed as AKB’s center since pretty much the beginning .Really, the thing about her that stands out is that she’s kind of the archetypal girl next door. She’s pretty, but seemingly attainable.

Basically I agree with Chiima; idols are capitalizing on what the individual girls have to offer, and marketing them.

Idol Thoughts: Do Idols Need Talent?

Recently I was browsing Maji De 2ch, a blog that posts translations of 2ch threads (2ch is basically an anonymous board that was the inspiration for 4chan. You can talk about anything but there is often discussion on idols). I like browsing the various sites that do 2ch translations, just because it’s often very interesting to hear about things that Japanese fans talk about.

The post that caught my attention was this one. Essentially, it’s reactions to a talk that Sashihara Rino did, where she said that, if you aim to be an idol, you don’t have to learn how to sing or dance.

(Translation from  the Maji de 2ch Page)

“Girls who can’t dance are cuter. They make you want to root for them”.
“Most idol fans these days are old men, right? These old men actually find the girls who can’t do anything cuter, and they’re happier when they tell a girl that ‘You’re totally no good!’. I think people are more attracted to idols who are giving it their all despite being really bad at it”.
This, understandably, is a fairly controversial statement about the nature of idols. So, what do I think?
…Sasshi’s partly right. BUT this is oversimplifying things.
Sasshi’s statement basically says that idols that can’t sing and dance are cuter, but they should be giving it their all. Which is a fairly key concept that I think would be easy to miss.
One of the defining features of the idol industry, in my opinion, is that it’s based on watching idols grow. The vast vast majority of girls who become idols have never done much of anything in the entertainment business before. Some may have modeled, or did commercials, but the point of the idol industry, especially the female idol industry, is that it’s a temporary stepping stone to another career. Therefore, it’s not necessarily a good thing for an idol to be polished from the getgo, because that’s not the point  of idols.
However, there  are some other things that I think need to be taken into consideration.
1. A fan might be drawn to an idol’s performing talent. 
People become a fan of an idol for a variety of reasons. Some like the cute girls, some like personality, some like this kind of “can’t do anything” type. However, some people like the talented girls.
For example, I don’t follow foreign fans of Hello!Project as much, but Tamura Meimi of S/Mileage has been getting buzz lately because of her vocal talent.

Meimi’s been a good vocalist for some time, but given some time to improve and given songs that show of her vocal skills, she’s been getting buzz, at least from Hello!Project fans.

I’d say this is similar with girls like Ishida Ayumi, as well. I became a fan of hers both because of her dance skills and because of her drive to become a good dancer.

This isn’t exclusively Hello!Project. AKB48 has had various singing contests and things, which allows girls like Iwasa Misaki and Takeuchi Miyu to shine. Natori Wakana is also a strong singer who gets notice for her voice. Would Iwasa Misaki have been able to rank at #33 last year (just out of the Undergirls) if she didn’t have her vocal skills and her brand new enka career? There’s no way to know for sure, but vocal skills can definitely help girls.

However, as a counterpoint, I don’t think JUST singing and dancing are the only things that can make a girl stand out. They’re the most popular talents to have, for sure, since being an idol means a lot of singing and dancing. However, AKB’s Matsui Sakiko is a very skilled pianist, which has allowed her a great deal of press.

2. Girls have to actually try and practice once they get in.

Being initially unpolished is fairly acceptable among idol fans. No one is going to expect a new trainee to AKB to be the best singer and dancer the group has seen. However, very few girls can make it if they don’t try, or don’t seem like they’re trying. Girls like Shimazaki Haruka are few and far between, and that type of push is a big gamble. One of the most popular things to show of idols is videos of them practicing, working hard. That’s the key here; practice and hard work are fairly essential, once you’re an idol. So while I’d say you don’t have to be inherently talented to get in, you have to at least try.

3. It’s all how a girl is marketed.

This is the big one. Inherently untalented idols can be popular IF they are marketed well. I mean, look at Sasshi herself. She’s not exceptionally talented, but plays this up, and plays up that she likes idols.

An idol who isn’t the most popular in her group but who does this exceptionally well is S/Mileage’s Nakanishi Kana. Kana, when she joined especially, isn’t particularly good at singing or dancing, and is kind of clumsy. However, it seems like she tries really hard and always looks happy about the whole thing. Recently, in S/Mileage’s latest single ‘Yattaruchan,’ Kana got a prominent role by having a spoken part that became the most notable thing about the song.

However, one of the most memorable instances was in the dance to Choto Mate Kudasai. In this, Kana purposely messes up, and jumps the wrong way. It’s a little thing, but it puts her front and center. It says that she and management are aware she isn’t the most talented, but they want to show her off anyway. This is important.

Ultimately, while I think that being talented can be an advantage, that ultimately it is mostly how a particular idol is marketed.

What do you think? Do you like talented idols or idols who aren’t very good at singing or dancing? Do you agree with Sasshi? Comment below and I’ll write a Your Thoughts post next week!

Idol Thoughts: Trainee Systems

I’m not making a Your Thoughts post this week because I didn’t get comments. 🙂 Honestly, I’m surprised it took this long to get to an Idol Thoughts without comments, so thank you to everyone who’s participated so far.

One thing I noticed while doing my TIF blog posts is that there are a lot of trainee systems out there. Even some smaller indie groups have trainees, even though they’re just performing at small, local venues. This, and recently becoming a fan of some Hello!Project trainees, has made me consider the whole system and its pros and cons.

The biggest pro to the industry is that it’s a barrier of entry to the main groups. It gives girls who win auditions a lot of training, a chance to build up a small fanbase of her own, and she gets to grow as an idol before she even makes her proper debut in the group. If girls aren’t up to the challenge of being idols, it gives them a chance to opt out, as well. This also allows for groups with lots of members like AKB to not have issues with their member counts; when one girl graduates, another fills the spot.

Really, the biggest problem on this from an industry standpoint is when there are too many good trainee candidates. The formation of the original Team 4 and the current Team 4 can be traced to the fact that there are just too many solid AKB kenkyuusei who work hard and want to be in the group. The trainee system doesn’t really work when trainees languish, waiting for debut, and not enough girls were leaving to justify the numbers of kenkyuusei. Yet you don’t want to stop having auditions to admit more girls in.

This also leads me to think about trainee groups like the Nice Girl Project trainees. Nice Girl Project is pretty much over. The Possible is making a comeback, true, but as a project there aren’t really any other acts. So what must it be like, to be a Nice Girl Trainee, knowing you probably won’t ever debut? Is being a trainee idol enough for some of these girls? It’s an interesting thought.

This makes things a bit harder on fans, too. I know I’m personally hesitant to follow any trainee, just because it’s harder to know if she’s going to go anywhere. Really, the first two trainees I’ve followed were Sekine Azusa (now of Up Up Girls) and Natori Wakana (now a full AKB member), but there was a lot of waiting and uncertainty with being a fan of them. Of course, idols can graduate whenever they want to, but being a trainee only adds to that.

Recently, I’ve become a fan of Sasaki Rikako and Funaki Musubu, both Hello!Project Kenshuusei (I still call them Eggs in my head). Rikako I have a bit more hope for, since she was the only member in her generation and is generally thought of as being a big possibility for being a future star, but there are a lot of H!P kenshuusei that never debut and just perform at concerts. Is it worth it to be a fan of girls this early? If you gamble right, it may pay off in small ways. I have photos of both Sekkii and Wakanyan from their early days, and I’m happy to be a long time fan of these girls. But for every trainee that debuts, there’s even more that have gone nowhere.

Also, I wonder how good of a system it all is. Yes, it provides some training. However, are the members that better prepared? And so many idol groups focus on the idea of “fresh” idols, that don’t have entertainment experience. This takes away that idea. Is it much different to provide girls with some fairly intensive training right before debut than to be training them occasionally over the course of some years?

What do you think about trainee systems? Do you like or dislike them? Comment and you too can be a part of Happy Disco with my “Your Thoughts” post that will be up next week!