Idol Thoughts: Trainee Systems

I’m not making a Your Thoughts post this week because I didn’t get comments. 🙂 Honestly, I’m surprised it took this long to get to an Idol Thoughts without comments, so thank you to everyone who’s participated so far.

One thing I noticed while doing my TIF blog posts is that there are a lot of trainee systems out there. Even some smaller indie groups have trainees, even though they’re just performing at small, local venues. This, and recently becoming a fan of some Hello!Project trainees, has made me consider the whole system and its pros and cons.

The biggest pro to the industry is that it’s a barrier of entry to the main groups. It gives girls who win auditions a lot of training, a chance to build up a small fanbase of her own, and she gets to grow as an idol before she even makes her proper debut in the group. If girls aren’t up to the challenge of being idols, it gives them a chance to opt out, as well. This also allows for groups with lots of members like AKB to not have issues with their member counts; when one girl graduates, another fills the spot.

Really, the biggest problem on this from an industry standpoint is when there are too many good trainee candidates. The formation of the original Team 4 and the current Team 4 can be traced to the fact that there are just too many solid AKB kenkyuusei who work hard and want to be in the group. The trainee system doesn’t really work when trainees languish, waiting for debut, and not enough girls were leaving to justify the numbers of kenkyuusei. Yet you don’t want to stop having auditions to admit more girls in.

This also leads me to think about trainee groups like the Nice Girl Project trainees. Nice Girl Project is pretty much over. The Possible is making a comeback, true, but as a project there aren’t really any other acts. So what must it be like, to be a Nice Girl Trainee, knowing you probably won’t ever debut? Is being a trainee idol enough for some of these girls? It’s an interesting thought.

This makes things a bit harder on fans, too. I know I’m personally hesitant to follow any trainee, just because it’s harder to know if she’s going to go anywhere. Really, the first two trainees I’ve followed were Sekine Azusa (now of Up Up Girls) and Natori Wakana (now a full AKB member), but there was a lot of waiting and uncertainty with being a fan of them. Of course, idols can graduate whenever they want to, but being a trainee only adds to that.

Recently, I’ve become a fan of Sasaki Rikako and Funaki Musubu, both Hello!Project Kenshuusei (I still call them Eggs in my head). Rikako I have a bit more hope for, since she was the only member in her generation and is generally thought of as being a big possibility for being a future star, but there are a lot of H!P kenshuusei that never debut and just perform at concerts. Is it worth it to be a fan of girls this early? If you gamble right, it may pay off in small ways. I have photos of both Sekkii and Wakanyan from their early days, and I’m happy to be a long time fan of these girls. But for every trainee that debuts, there’s even more that have gone nowhere.

Also, I wonder how good of a system it all is. Yes, it provides some training. However, are the members that better prepared? And so many idol groups focus on the idea of “fresh” idols, that don’t have entertainment experience. This takes away that idea. Is it much different to provide girls with some fairly intensive training right before debut than to be training them occasionally over the course of some years?

What do you think about trainee systems? Do you like or dislike them? Comment and you too can be a part of Happy Disco with my “Your Thoughts” post that will be up next week!

One thought on “Idol Thoughts: Trainee Systems”

  1. Pingback: Recommended Jpop♀ Reading: October 2013, Part Two | Idolminded

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *