Idol Thoughts: Idols and Standards of Beauty

Since the first time a TV appearance was put online, I’ve been really into AKB’s Koisuru Fortune Cookie. (And yes, part of that is because I’m in the fan version, which still doesn’t get old to think about).

But aside from the catchy song and the various versions of people dancing to it, one thing that people don’t necessarily focus on are the lyrics.

One of the most telling lines in the song is: (Thank you Stage48)

“”A girl with a good personality would be nice” is what all the boys say
But looks are an advantage
The ones that always get first place in popularity contests are cute girls
Please! Please! Please! Oh baby!
Look at me!”

The song is focusing on a girl who isn’t attractive, but wants to be noticed as well. The song doesn’t say “Oh actually, she’s beautiful” but is from the point of view of someone who isn’t attractive.

This is a fairly common theme in songs centered by Sashihara Rino (wow, sorry Sasshi). Her first single, Sore Demo Suki Da yo features lyrics like (Again, thanks Stage48)

“Within the group,
I’m a plain type
My chest is underwhelming,
and I’m completely without pheromones
There are girls much cuter than I am”

with the song basically being about a girl wanting to be confessed to, saying “even still, I still like you.” The lyrics don’t deny her looks at all.

Sasshi’s duet with Watanabe Mayu, Avocado Janeeshi, also is on this topic (Stage48)

“Even so (even so)
I’m pretty useless
I’m not cute (I’m not confident)
and I’m losing to the other girls around
It’s annoying, ah?”

The song’s main part compares the girl to an avocado, being an avocado among other, nicer smelling/tasting fruits (though avocados make guacamole, so there’s nothing wrong with a good avocado in my opinion).

While this is a common theme with songs featuring Sashihara Rino (which I think is kind of unfair, because IMO Sasshi’s definitely pretty), it comes up in other songs. Take the AKB48 B-side, Boku Dake no Value. (S48)

“If we had a popularity election in our class
You wouldn’t rank in the top positions
You’re average at both school and sports
You’re the type that doesn’t stand out

But somehow
I always think about you
Wherever I am…”

While this is a more common theme in AKB48 than, say, Hello!Project, it’s not absent there. From the line in v-u-den’s Ajisai Ai Ai Monogatari where they sing about the person preferring better looking girls (and Okada Yui sings about large breasts, which always makes me giggle), to Nakazawa Yuko singing in Tokyo Bijin about how she’ll ‘turn into a Tokyo hag’,’ it shows up there, though less apparent and less frequently.

Compare this to some Western pop tunes, like the One Direction hit (and only One Direction song I’ve ever heard) “What Makes You Beautiful.”

“You’re insecure,
Don’t know what for,
You’re turning heads when you walk through the door,
Don’t need make-up,
To cover up,
Being the way that you are is enough,”

Basically, the girl in question isn’t ugly or plain; she’s gorgeous and turning heads without make-up. But she’s even MORE attractive because she’s insecure and doesn’t know she’s pretty.

Now, this isn’t necessarily saying that beauty isn’t at play in the JPop world more so than Hollywood. Popular idols generally tend to be good looking. However, one thing that I still think about is the whole charm point phenomenon, where it’s seen as attractive or desirable to have a flaw. Then you have girls like Sashihara Rino, who is seen by many as being a fairly plain person (though, again, I think she’s really pretty) winning out in the senbatsu election over other, arguably better looking girls.

The idol world is made up of young, cute/pretty/beautiful girls. However, what I’ve found in my fandom is a space where it’s OK to be a bit strange looking or different looking, and it’s OK to be a bit weird. For all the talk about Suzuki Kanon of Morning Musume being “fat,” at least there’s a place for a larger girl to be in an idol group. You CAN have someone like Suzuki Kanon or AD Nagisa of Bakusute Sotokanda Icchome, or even SDN48’s Nachu.

I’m not saying it’s completely easy or even if you’re unattractive, but just that it can be done with the idol world, and certain songs embrace it. Which I think is a lovely thing.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and I’ll include it in next week’s Your Thoughts post!

Your Thoughts: Line Distribution

This week I only got one response, but boy was it one I was excited to get! Vince, a big Super Girls fan, gave his take on the group, the fandom, and promotion/line distribution in the group.

Vince wrote: As for SUPER☆GiRLS, while they have placed Ami, Ruka and Saori up in the front, it doesn’t really feel like you’re missing out if your oshi is another girl. As a Mirei oshi, I’m almost led to believe she’s the ace (or well, 2nd after Ami) when watching CMs or their most recent drama. Even during concerts I feel like they’re filming her literally all the time (and wow did she pick up lines when Kaede left).

There’s also the general consensus that if you’ve got a problem with Ami or Ruka, just close the door on the way out. :P
Now this is just my personal opinion, but I don’t think Spaga is a group where you just walk in, pick a favorite member and follow only her. While they do have individual activities now and then, I think management spends a lot of effort pushing them as a -group-. The fact that they don’t add new members kinda underline this too.

Fandom isn’t all that large though, especially not in the west.
Sorry for the long rant but, my group you know :D

Just a couple of things; I’m mostly just excited to see something from a Spaga fan’s perspective, because I don’t follow the group enough to consider myself an expert.

1. I think this brings up the good point of what the lead brings to a group. “There’s also the general consensus that if you’ve got a problem with Ami or Ruka, just close the door on the way out.” I think this is true for a lot of groups, though not necessarily every group. For example, Maeda Atsuko had a lot of antis and people who disliked her, but these people considered themselves fans. However, I know it was hard for me to follow Morning Musume when Aika was my favorite, just because I never cared for Ai or Reina, which lead me to holding off on the group until I became a 10th gen fan.

I do think there are groups, though, where if you dislike the lead it makes it very hard to like the rest of the group. If you want to like AeLL, you better like Shinozaki Ai.

2. The concept of a group being promoted as a whole; I think this is truer for a lot of lesser known groups. AKB is promoted as a whole, but really they encourage you to root for your favorite member. But I don’t think this is necessarily the case for a lot of smaller groups. I feel comfortable having multiple favorites and rooting for every member of Dempagumi.inc, because I feel like they are pushing the group as a big unit. When I follow the groups that are even more indie, like Rev.from DVL and Rhymeberry, while I have favorite members (Miki and Yuka, respectively), I want the group as a unit to succeed, and I genuinely like all of them.

So thank you Vince for your insight; I appreciate your comment. 🙂

Idol Thoughts: Line Distribution

By reading that title, I’m sure some of you shuddered. Line distribution. The dreaded topic of many idol fans.

One thing I’ve noticed, in my days as an idol fan, is that it seems to be a primary concern mainly for Hello! Project fans. It seems like with every single, or even every performance, is concerned with who got the most lines, who deserved solo lines, who didn’t deserve solo lines. This is just something I don’t see with many other groups, like AKB48 or Momoiro Clover Z. Sure, people may complain that a girl gets pushed forward too much, but no one really complains about who sings what.

This seems to be for a pretty obvious reason; AKB48 doesn’t focus as much on solo lines. However, I don’t see many people complaining about it in the Momoiro Clover Z fan groups, even if Kanako gets a big solo in favor of the other members singing. I think with Momoiro Clover Z, though, there’s more of an expectation that Kanako will get a big solo line. The line distribution is relatively fair, anyways, so occasional unevenness is forgiven.

The biggest thing, though, that sets H!P apart is just how tied together solo lines and how visible an idol is. Take Resonant Blue. The song is dominated by Takahashi Ai and Tanaka Reina, with some singing by Kusumi Koharu. There are bits from Niigaki Risa and Kamei Eri, one “Help Me!” from Michishige Sayumi, and pretty much nothing from Mitsui Aika, JunJun and LinLin. If you’re a fan of anyone other than Ai, Reina and Koharu, you barely see your favorite in the PV.

Since Hello!Project doesn’t have much of a TV presence as they once did, PVs are a very significant way you see your idol. For many Hello!Project fans, solo lines are related to close up shots and ways you see your favorite.

Still, I have to wonder about other groups. I don’t follow Super Girls’ fans as much; is the amount of exposure, say, Maeshima Ami gets a spot of contention? Do Passpo fans argue about the line distribution? Or is this almost a completely Hello!Project phenomenon.

As for what I think about line distribution, I think it really depends on what the group is going for. If you’re emphasizing the vocal skills of some while everyone dances (i.e. Fairies, Dancing Dolls), then this shouldn’t be compromised (though I think those groups really do a good job of promoting all their idols and not just focusing on the singing ones). However, if every member theoretically could thing, I think they really should sing.

Back in the platinum era of Morning Musume, it was hard to be a fan of a back girl. I really liked Mitsui Aika, but focusing on a girl who rarely got any kind of solo part or close up was flat out frustrating. I would often buy the songs off itunes, but I never thought of buying the physical singles, just because the songs focused too much on Ai and Reina. Nothing against those girls and their fans, but Reina and Ai just aren’t idols I particularly care about.

While many people remember Platinum era Musume fondly, their sales were declining. The group really wasn’t doing all that well, and, to be honest, I thought they would be close to disbanding around now. However, the group is doing very well now, even though conventional wisdom was that when a girl left, sales dropped. Why is it doing so well? Well, the idol boom has something to do with it. Idols are doing well in general now. Also their overall production level is up. You might not like the current music or PVs, but they have been putting more into both of these. However, I think the variety of girls in the group makes it even easier. If you don’t like Sayashi Riho or Oda Sakura, you might like Fukumura Mizuki. Or Ishida Ayumi. Or Sato Masaki. As much as people complain about, say, Suzuki Kanon’s lines, it’s easier to be a fan of more girls now than it was in the platinum era. Even if a couple of girls might not get many solo lines, they do a good job of giving everyone a little something, or more close ups. It’s not perfectly even by any means, but it’s better, which I think has to make a difference.

Still, this relates to my topic last week. If an idol is in the background, it’s harder to be a fan of her. The more girls that someone could be an easy fan of, the more potential fans you have. A more even line distribution, while not something that will guarantee sales growth, certainly can’t hurt.

Your Thoughts: The Death of the Solo Idol?

This week I got one response to my thoughts about solo idols. However, what a response it was! Steve from Selective Hearing wrote an article about his thoughts on solo idols. Now, since I won’t quote everything he wrote; you should just go read what he said. However, here’s a few of my thoughts on his response.

“As far as competing in the idol market today, in sales and popularity, I think soloists don’t even stand a chance, and the sales numbers and happenstance of the last few years seem to support this.”

I think this is very true. Steve goes on to describe how large groups allow people the idea that they can choose, and encourages people to only have one favorite (oshimen). Even though AKB48 isn’t my top idol group, even when I wasn’t really a big fan of the songs I felt like I should still follow the group. Now recently I’ve become a fan of Kawaei Rina, and that’s because there’s a big group to encourage variety. I don’t necessarily think this is a bad thing; I would say the majority of AKB48 girls would stand a chance as a soloist. That said, I like that I can be a fan of a girl who isn’t exceptionally talented or cut out to be a solo idol. I liked following Hata Sawako, the girl who was extremely shy. I like that there’s a girl like Shimazaki Haruka out there.

That said, I definitely agree that large groups like AKB48 make it difficult to justify a soloist idol. Steve also mentions that the popularity of soloist idols is almost certainly because of their group, which I would agree with. However, I think it could be a bit more complicated than that. A friend of mine became a fan of Watanabe Mayu’s primarily through her solo work, and I know I’ve gained an appreciation for Mayu because of that. I’ve personally gained a bit of interest in Yokoyama Rurika from Idoling because of her solo career. She may have gotten her start through Idoling, but I know it piqued my interest in her. That said, while it may promote the group, I’d say the majority of the popularity comes from the group, not from the soloist.

In his article, Steve brings up the decline in solo idol acts, which it’s impossible to refute. However, I have to wonder about the economics of the whole situation. I know that usually the rationale goes “larger idol group = more fans = more profit,” but there are a lot of girls in AKB who aren’t popular. The majority of the money is driven by the top senbatsu members, and there are a lot of other girls who have to be paid (though idol acts don’t necessarily pay well). Could a smaller idol act be more profitable than a larger one, simply because a larger one takes up more resources? I suppose if this was the case, there would be more smaller acts. However, I think a lot of companies are trying to emulate the 48 group success. When that dies down, could solo idols make a comeback at all?

Steve also brings up a good point when bringing up soloists who do songs for anime and dramas. One of my favorite idols is Aso Natsuko, a soloist. She’s not very popular, and her biggest selling single did well because it was the opening theme to the anime “Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu.” However, even though she doesn’t sell very well, this has allowed her to keep going and have a fairly steady solo career. That said, she didn’t start singing because she was a seiyuu or for this anime, but she does release singles primarily as themes for something or another.

Steve also mentioned Idoling!!!, and wonders if the group focusing on solo efforts is part of a larger management that’s less risk-averse than, say, Hello!Project counterparts. This may be true, but Idoling’s biggest asset is its TV show on Fuji TV. Since Idoling was formed for this show, it’s a huge part of their identity, I’d say more than any one single or music release. The fact they have this relatively guaranteed support from Fuji TV, this allows them to be a little more risky with their music releases. Just a theory, though.

I would like to see more soloist idols, though. Matsuura Aya is one of my favorite idols of all time, and I love that she was able to perform on her own. She was an extremely charismatic and compelling idol, and I think she did better as a soloist than in any of the side groups she was placed in. I also think it’s a better venue for the more talented girls out there; I had no idea that Yokoyama Rurika was such a talented vocalist from my very casual Idoling fandom. However, her solo career has given me a new appreciation of her. From my experience meeting Aso Natsuko, there’s something special about watching an idol command a stage by herself, and I hope that more soloists debut soon. There’s a place for large groups and soloists, and I hope both of them find a place to coexist.

Idol Thoughts: The Death of the Solo Idol?

Since I reviewed an older idol song/PV for this week’s Review Monday, I’ve had older idols on my mind. In fact, I’m going to put out an additional blog post sometime this week involving that. However, one trend I’ve noticed (a very obvious trend, mind you) is that solo idols used to be more prominent and now idol groups are a bigger deal. The idol group isn’t a completely recent phenomenon; look at the success of Candies, The Peanuts, Pink Lady and Onyanko Club. However, the idol world was dominated by solo acts like Yamaguchi Momoe, Matsuda Seiko and others. In the early 2000s Matsuura Aya was a major solo force. And now, who are the main soloists in the idol world?

Let me ask a question, first off. Can anyone think of a solo idol working today that’s relatively popular but didn’t start off in a group? Mano Erina (though she’s graduated) started off in Ongaku Gatas. Kikkawa You is an option, but she started off in Milky Way. The most popular solo acts (by sales at least) are the AKB idols who are doing a solo career. Yokoyama Rurika is still an Idoling!!! member. During my TIF posts I came across some solo idols, but they hardly sell anything and are only known in their small niche in the idol fandom. One of my favorite idols is Aso Natsuko, who started as a soloist, but her sales depend mainly on what anime she’s doing the theme song for.

The point is, idol soloists are hard to come by. And why is that? I think that’s part of the AKB strategy for things. One of the reasons AKB has been so successful is because there are so many different, varied members. If you’re an idol fan and you can’t find a girl and a song you like in AKB or its sister groups, you probably haven’t looked hard enough. The lineup changes mean that your favorite might move to senbatsu, or they’ll be in one of the b-side groups, so you may still want that single. A solo idol has to appeal to every single fan, which means she has to be that more appealing.

Another thing a soloist idol has to be is some level of charismatic. She has to be able to command a stage, or at least put on a good show on her own. This isn’t something every idol can do. However, you don’t need to be completely charismatic if you can rely on other members. This is the same with singing ability. While there have been some solo idols who don’t have good voices (looking at you, Kusumi Koharu), most of them have pretty solid vocals. Mano Erina was never the best vocalist ever, but she wasn’t a bad vocalist. But being able to carry a song on your own vocals is something you need to do.

At this point, it’s hard to think a solo idol could become as big as the groups, and I’m wondering if any of the big idol agencies right now are even going to attempt to promote a solo idol with no prior experience. But what do you think? Do you think solo idols are over? Could a solo idol become big? Leave a comment and you too will be a part of my Your Thoughts post next week!

Your Thoughts: On the Janken Senbatsu

Right after I posted this post about AKB’s Janken tournament, a friend of mine (who has for some reason decided to just not comment on my blog at all =P) brought something to my attention, and that’s that last year Shimazaki Haruka only used scissors during the tournament (and then won) and that this year Matsui Jurina only used paper (and won). This has changed my opinion from “it may or may not be rigged” to ‘yeah it’s probably rigged.”

However, despite the fact that the winner is probably chosen by management, I still stand by that I don’t think the entire tournament is rigged. My friend and I both agree that even though the top position may have been rigged these past two years to support Paruru and Jurina, that it’s still a really fun tournament that gives a good chance to the rest of the members. In this past week the positions for the final single were finalized. Two things that amazed me were that Hirata Rina is #3 in the single and Natori Wakana is #6. These are two girls that have never been in a senbatsu before and have rarely been pushed, but are now at high positions. The #2 in the single is Kameida Emika, a member of NMB’s Team BII, who gets some decent promotion in NMB but still hasn’t been senbatsu in NMB yet either. And now these girls get a lot of promotion in AKB, which is the fun of the janken tournament.

Commenter Mozenator wrote: 

I have to think it’s rigged somehow. Like you said though, ‘why Jurina?” MAybe they worked out some deal with her? I mean they are all actors, being an Idol is a type of act, if you think people can be that cute and happy all the time..lol c’mon! Some go as far as to create an whole new character, most just exaggerate personality traits they already have…

What I’m saying is it’s all built on illusion, the Idol world. It would be nice if this were a true contest and a certain HKT Kenshuusei could get center for an AKB single..or Miyu Takeuchi or Lemon (my 3 top personal choices). But it seems management has other ideas. A shame really. I still think it’s fun just not as much now.

If it weren’t for the “one-hand-sign-all-the-way-thru” thing for two winners in a row…I would be a ton less wary..still can’t wait to catch the costumes!

First off, I totally agree that it’s rigged now, just based on the one hand sign all the way through. So I agree with you there.

That said, while there is an illusion of chance for this competition to a degree, I don’t think it completely diminishes the tournament. Every idol may not be able to get #1, but they can get #3 and so on. As a long-term Natori Wakana fan, I’m incredibly happy that she managed to get into senbatsu, because she barely gets any screentime in what little she gets in AKB (basically team songs and if there’s a really big undergirls group). Does this make it a little less exciting? A bit, yeah. I know my favorites won’t be able to achieve #1 (well, maybe Kawaei Rina could make it next year, she’s getting a pretty big push. However, if we accept that management is going to put whoever they want in the #1 slot, then we can focus on the excitement of the rest. A bit of a cop out, I know, and I do wish that everything was left up to chance. However, maybe it’s because of my own personal biases, I still like the janken tournament.

As for why Jurina, I still can’t figure that out. As for it all being an act… I mean, I guess to a degree. Some idols do have “characters,” too (I know that for a time in Morning Musume they actively encouraged girls to get a specific personality down). However, some people are happier than others, especially at their job. Currently I work a retail job, and it’s one where I’m not necessarily happy about it. I wish I was doing something else, I wish I got paid more, I’m just not satisfied at my job. However, I have a smile every day, and I’m genuinely happy to be there. I like helping people, and I like making people a bit happier because they were helped by someone who was positive. I’m not saying every idol’s like me, or that every idol is happy, but I think people put a bit too much into “It’s all an act!” Yeah not everyone is happy all the time, but I personally like being happy, and try to put on a happy face even if on the inside I’m unhappy. This is something that pretty much everyone does; the chipper waiter or the happy realtor who sells you their home may be “faking” their emotions. But this is something pretty much everyone does, so I think calling idol culture an illusion is taking it a bit too far, simply because that’s something common in culture.

(note that this isn’t just aimed at you and I’m sorry if it seems this way; this is just something I’ve been thinking about for a while).

Steve S commented: 

Just like Mozenator said, so much of this is just based on illusion and staging things to appear a certain way, and ever since the previous tournament, I’ve thought these are far more staged than before. At least the first two actually did have a number of unknown girls near the top, these ones have kinda become just a joke.

On the whole thing about Jurina winning, whether she misses a lot or not, this could’ve just been a kind of underhanded way to try to convince her to not miss as much, maybe, by purposely choosing her as an ultimatum. I seem to remember quite a few AKB performances in the past where the center was not there for one reason or another, so it does happen, which also brings into question whether or not they even care if the center is there if its not some huge, national performance on a huge TV show or something.

I really can’t take much of anything they do very seriously anymore after discovering more idol groups who don’t have the same kind of generic, transparent “act” about them that we’ve been seeing for the last 25~ years, but this kind of stuff just pushes it over the limit for me and a little further away from the group as a whole.

First off, I think this actually has a decent amount of unknown girls near the top. The #2 and #3 are relatively unknown, and I’d say the majority of this year’s janken senbatsu is pretty interesting. The only girl who’s pretty famous that’s high up there is Kitahara Rie. There are girls that are known with certain people (Oba Mina, Tano Yuka, Kikuchi Ayaka), but there’s a really big lack of girls who are pushed and high up with the senbatsu. In fact, I’d say this is more of an unknown group than last year, excepting the center. Maeda Atsuko was in the first janken senbatsu, Kojima Haruna was in the first two, and the third senbatsu (with a rigged center) also featured Itano Tomomi, Shinoda Mariko, and Kashiwagi Yuki. This year’s senbatsu is the most unknown group yet, which is exciting (despite the center being most likely rigged).

As for Jurina herself, perhaps it is an underhanded way, but I’d personally prefer them to focus her on one group. Not because I want AKB to remain just AKB or anything like that, but I know that Jurina has had health issues in the past and has had to miss a lot because of that. I’m not saying that’s why she missed so much in Koisuru Fortune Cookie, but I think choosing to overexert a member who’s already having issues with overexerting herself is bad news. Even still, you’re right in that the center could be covered, so it’s not like it’ll make a HUGE difference, but it still puzzles me since there are other members they’ve been trying to push.

I know you’re not super into this type of thing, and I don’t blame you, especially after finding out more about what you personally care about (note: Steve and I are Facebook friends and follow each other on twitter, so I know a bit about his personal tastes). Personally, I go back and forth on AKB; I love individual members and songs, but when the music quality goes down I stop caring. However, I enjoy these big AKB wide events, just because it’s something to care about beyond record sales. It’s another bit of excitement to write about or follow. I like being able to have my little bit of drama with the senbatsu election. I know it’s not to everyone’s tastes, but it helps some of my favorites out and I think it’s fun, regardless if there’s a little rigging in there.

Idol Thoughts: On the Janken Senbatsu

Today one of the biggest events in the AKB48 year occured; the Janken contest. Basically, every year (this was the fourth) AKB holds a giant rock-paper-scissors contest to determine the lineup for the last single of the year.

And this is the second year in a row that people have accused the contest of being rigged. (though a small number of people may have said it in the years past)

There’s no actual proof, mind you, just the fact that the past few years that popular members have won, as opposed to someone lesser known. Shimazaki Haruka winning last year made a lot of people question the validity of the tournament, and now Matsui Jurina winning has seemed to seal the deal for a lot of people.

Personally, while there are other members I would have wished to win the tournament, Jurina winning doesn’t make me automatically think “this was rigged.” First off, there are plenty of other members who would make more sense to push. Jurina is already popular, but AKB wants to promote girls like Iriyama Anna, Kato Rena, Kawaei Rina, etc. She already has a lot of singles she centers, and one more wouldn’t make the difference. Secondly, Jurina misses a lot; due to illness or just exhaustion, she’s missed a fair deal lately. I watched quite a bit of the live Koisuru Fortune Cookie performances, and Jurina missed the majority of them. Would management really rig something where the center might not perform for most of the performances, or where it’s even a question?

Another thing that I’ve thought of is the purpose of the single, which is almost undoubtedly to give lesser known girls a chance to shine. There’s nothing stopping AKB management from putting unknown girls in the senbatsu for a single, but it’s generally accepted that they don’t. This is an excuse for having a really unusual, interesting group of girls perform. I mean, that was the whole cool thing about having the center for the first Janken election be Uchida Mayumi; Ucchi wasn’t really known until the election. So I can see where a lot of people are coming from, being disappointed. I mean, I’m kind of disappointed myself; I like having unknown girls win.

However, even if the center isn’t necessarily unknown, there’s usually some lesser known girls, which makes things really great. I’m a huge fan of Natori Wakana, so I’m REALLY happy that she made it into her first senbatsu, and I’m really excited for Hirata Rina too. Even if it doesn’t necessarily make members more popular, it’s a really exciting and happy time for girls who don’t get pushed very much and don’t have as many opportunities in AKB. So even if this happened to be rigged (which again I’m not sure if I think that), I’m still happy the janken senbatsu exists,, mostly because it’s a really great thing for some girls who don’t normally get that chance.

Anyways, what do you think? Do you think the janken tournament is rigged? Do you like the concept of the Janken senbatsu? Let me know in the comments!

Your Thoughts: Idols in America

As expected for my first Idol Thoughts post, I didn’t get that much responses. The people who I talked to and didn’t comment seemed fairly skeptical about the concept of an idol group in the US. A friend of mine thought that an American girl group would inevitably end up selling sex and being a failure. This is kind of a common sentiment, and an interesting thought; could a girl group be not a sexy group and succeed in the US? I’m not sure if it could.

Mara from Fly in the F*Ing Wine commented: OMG I still have that B*Witched CD! That is awesome! Girl Radical kind of sounds like an R & B version of FAKY to me. The makeup of the group also really looks like a group that Japanese fans envisioned an American AKB looking like. I hope it takes off, but I’m not overly optimistic about it.

Cool to see another person had a B*Witched CD! Makes me wonder if there are any common links between music that people followed before they got into idols; while I’ve been into indie rock for sometime, when I was in elementary school I was way into the Radio Disney type pop groups (B*Witched, S Club 7, *NSYNC, etc), which I really consider the precursor to my idol fandom.

I also really like the makeup of the group; I’m glad to see that it seems like a really diverse bunch of girls, and not just a group of all-white, tall skinny girls. This is the most positive of the group as of yet, IMO.

But I share your sentiment, and I think that’s a commonly-heard one. I’m skeptical and not sure it’ll do well, but I definitely hope it does well.

Idol Thoughts: Idols in America

This is the first of my new series, idol thoughts, where every Wednesday I write something I’ve thought of recently and I invite guest responses! So please comment and I’ll include it in next week’s post.

A while back I was alerted to the new project by former *NSYNC member J.C. Chasez, Girl Radical. This is a currently 12 member girl group that he’s said was inspired by AKB48; on their official website it even states that it’s “Inspired by the trend of giant girl groups in Japan.” So it’s fair to say that, even if this isn’t the words that he’s directly used, that this is trying to be an idol project in the US.

Needless to say I’ve been intrigued. KPop has had an interesting relationship with the US (what with everyone thinking it was the next big thing and that just not happening yet), but JPop isn’t something that’s been attempted. I was actually a big *NSYNC fan back in the day, but girl groups have rarely had much pull in the US. Sure there were the Spice Girls, but they were a British group and one. I personally was a big fan of the girl group B*Witched (OK did I like asterisks or what?) but how many people actually remember them? Female pop stars are still really huge in the US, but is there room for girl groups? I’ve only seen skepticism for this group.

As an idol group, I actually think they’re doing a pretty good job of emphasizing personality. All the members have twitter accounts, there’s a Facebook page, and there’s a youtube channel where they’ve done some webisodes to try and show some of the members’ personality. This basically feels like a Japanese indie idol group would; they don’t have a TV show (and really, I doubt any American music act is going to get a show like AKBingo, since variety TV isn’t a big thing in the US). They don’t have much up yet, but I think it would be good if they kept it up.

Really, the biggest thing they absolutely need right now is some radio time and a good song. They only have a cover of No Doubt’s Just a Girl on their Youtube (as a No Doubt fan as well, I’m really surprised at how many of my interests converge here). Some news outlets are starting to write a little about this group, but until they have a big, popular song I don’t think people will much care about this group.

I’m a bit pleasantly surprised by what I’ve seen so far, but I still don’t know how the idol concept will translate to the US, if at all. I’d like to support more girl groups in the US, but I’m really not sure if they’re going to take off.

What do you think? Do you think girl groups could take off in the US? Could a group based on AKB48 in the US be popular? Should this even be attempted? Comment below!