Review Monday: NMB48 “Kimi to deatte Boku ga Kawatta” & HKT48 “Wink wa Sankai”

Back to our regular schedule this week! There’s still one more end of 2013 list coming up (PVs) but that’s going to be in one of the next couple of List Fridays.

Today I’m going to review the last two 48 group tracks from AKB48’s Suzukake Nanchara single. Because I don’t want to leave that undone.

Kimi to Deatte Boku ga Kawatta – NMB48

Song: Something about this reminds me of an anime opening. I don’t know if it’s a specific opening or just a generic anime opening feel, but the melody plus the string-heavy arrangement gives me some serious anime opening/ending vibes. This isn’t a bad thing; I mean, that’s part of how I got interested in Japanese music, was through liking the opening/ending themes back when anime was still a thing I followed.

As such, the melody does feel like a mix of generic and unique; the song as written is something I know I’ve heard before, but not necessarily with a lot of idols, and at least not with a lot of idols recently. It’s not bad, but it’s not the most memorable thing ever. I enjoy it, though, and it makes me feel oddly nostalgic.

The arrangement fits well into this, with very strings-heavy instrumentation with some piano thrown in there. It’s very pleasant, and feels like it fits the song nicely, but it’s hard not to compare it to something like Bokura no Eureka, NMB’s other major string-heavy song of the year. Perhaps this is unfair; these are two entirely different songs. This is just where my mind went, though. The arrangement fits the song well, though.

All in all, this is a really pleasant song. It’s not quite as exciting as last year’s “Ha!” but it’s an easy to like song. 7/10

PV:

kimitodeatte1

 

A gag at the end; now that’s something that feels like NMB.

This PV is essentially NMB48’s travel brochure to go visit Osaka. Which I actually really like. The other 48 PVs have been fine so far, but don’t necessarily feel like they are inherently meant for their group. SKE is generally a cooler group with emphasis on dancing and choreography, and they got that, but it’s still not the same. NMB48 has always had a pretty solid focus on being an group from Osaka, and this feels like their love letter to the city.

kimitodeatte2

The conceit of the PV is that the group is on a school trip to Osaka and are visiting locations. It’s not really necessary; all the shots in Osaka should be enough. But it’s a nice touch to show why they’re running around Osaka.

kimitodeatte3

 

As usual the PV is shot very well, but pretty much all 48 PVs have a high production standard. I like these low angle shots throughout the PVs. It allows for some interesting looking shots that show off some of the Osaka scenery, but it also adds a fairly unique visual style to the PV.

kimitodeatte4

 

A lot of the PV is just walking around in Osaka, but it made me want to go visit the place, so I think they achieved what they were looking for.

kimitodeatte5The dance shot is absolutely lovely, filmed in the evening in front of Osaka Castle. I know that filming an outdoor shot at night is risky, but this absolutely paid off. This is one of the best looking dance shot locations I’ve seen.

This PV is a whole lot of fun, shows off Osaka, and looks lovely. I think it’s easily the best PV of this single so far, and a very nice PV overall. 8/10

Wink wa Sankai

Song:

It’s hard not to compare this to Hatsukoi Butterfly, HKT’s song from last year. After all, that was HKT48’s first original song, and really set the pace for HKT48. Wink wa Sankai is unfortunately not as memorable as Hatsukoi Butterfuly.

I do like the guitar-heavy arrangement and rock-focused song; Melon Juice was a fantastic single, and I’m glad that they’ve continued with this motif at least for a while. The biggest problem is with the melody and the song itself. It just isn’t very memorable or interesting. The chorus part of “Wink wa Sankai” is fairly easy to remember, but I can’t bring myself to keep the rest of the song’s melody in my head. It would be one thing if the song was in any way interesting, but it’s not.

That said, I do like the chorus a fair amount. I’m a sucker for the response “yeah yeah yeah yeah” parts. And really, this isn’t bad, it’s just not as good as I wish it was. I love some of the electric guitar solos in here and the chorus is good. It’s just, when it comes down to it, the song as a whole isn’t as interesting or good as it should be from these parts. Which is a shame, to be honest. Melon Juice is one of the best 48 single songs of the year (after Koisuru Fortune Cookie and Bokura no Eureka), so if there was a little more of that I think this would have been better.

There are some good parts, but, as a whole, Wink wa Sankai isn’t as good as it should have been. 6/10

PV:

Last year Hatsukoi Butterfly decided to surprise everyone and put kenkyuusei Tashima Meru up center. This year’s new center is Yabuki Nako.

winkwasankai1

 

Nako, where have you been all my life. She is cute, charismatic, and I really enjoyed her as center. Meru’s fine, and I don’t dislike her, but Yabuki Nako has oodles of potential within HKT and I’m excited to see where she goes.

winkwasankai2

The conceit of this PV is that HKT48 discovers that their winks can cause the boys (and Sasshi?) at school to fall over and/or have heart attacks. Well. That’s something.

winkwasankai3

 

The comic book style graphics on the screen add a lot of character and personality to this PV; it’s kind of a necessary addition, mind you, otherwise the whole point of the PV would be kind of confusing, but it still looks nice and adds a lot of color.

winkwasankai4

One thing I love is how far they take the silliness of this PV. The girls don’t just use it on boys they like; they use it in interesting ways and for their own personal gain. Sasshi becomes a wink sniper, hitting guys from a distance. They use it to win at table tennis and kendo. They aren’t being cutesy about it; they are using their cuteness as a straight up weapon.

winkwasankai6

 

winkwasankai5

 

The dance shot is very Heavy Rotation-esque in how colorful it is. It’s not as fun as the rest of the PV, but that’s a tricky thing.

This PV is fun, has a lot of humor, and shows off its new center well. It has an interesting visual style on top of that. 9/10

Review Monday: AKB48 “Party is Over” + SKE48 “Escape”


Last week I reviewed the title track and main B-Side to the latest AKB single. Now it’s time to take a look at the other tracks, the individual group ones!

AKB48 – Party is Over

Song: This title makes me NERVOUS. Since AKB48’s first song they ever performed was “Party ga Hajimaru yo,” the idea of doing a song talking about the party ending immediately makes me a bit anxious.

Still, if this song is indication of the party that’s ending, it’s a party that I’m glad is over. This is not a very good song. I’m hardly a big fan of a lot of slow songs, but I do like a good ballad if there’s emotion to it. This is slow, emotionless, and drags on far longer than it should. The instrumentation is quite nice, and I wish that there could be a more interesting song for this type of instrumental, but there isn’t.

I feel like the biggest tragedy here is the intro of the song; it sounds really cool, like it would be an interesting idol song… then nope, you’ve got Party is Over. I even had hope for the song once it changed styles, but then the verse went on too long and with an uninteresting melody. Again, there’s potential in the arrangement and instrumentation, but this song is the definition of dragging.

The chorus is better, and hints at a more interesting song, but that’s the one part that goes far too quickly. There’s also an out of place dubstep break which is OK on its own, but baffling here.

Like always, AKB48 songs are polished and this is no exception. There are elements here that, used in a better song, would be fine. This is just not that good of a song. Add to that that this is really not my type of song, and I can’t see myself listening to this for fun. Ever. 3/10

PV: Despite my feelings about this song, the PV is quite nice. It’s not really a PV based on a story, but it’s well shot and generally fits the tone of the song.

partyisover1

The dance shots look great. They aren’t silhouettes but the dark outfits and the light background make a very striking appearance which adds a whole lot to the PV. It’s overall a really nice looking dance shot.

partyisover2

 

I know I’ve railed against flat lighting before here but, H!P, this is how you do flat lighting. It’s used to create a somber mood that fits the song, but it also looks  good. It feels like it was intentionally shot this way, to give it that mood. The background does a lot to make it look interesting, too. So I don’t necessarily hate flat lighting  techniques, because when it’s done well and with a purpose it can be really nice. It’s just not always used well.

partyisover3

partyisover6

 

The whole PV was shot very nicely in terms of framing. I like the use of the set/props as well as how they never seem to be afraid to use asymmetry in a shot. Too often most PVs center the idol, whereas this one tended to have some interesting shots. There’s only one shot I really thought was particularly poor, and that’s this shot of Kawaei Rina.

partyisover7Because generally putting the chin on the bottom of the frame and the top of the frame right at the top of the head isn’t the best technique. But this shot isn’t used that much (and it’s Kawaei Rina, so I’m inclined to let it slide).

The only thing that baffles me is the editing; at some points it feels like they’re just trying to fit in all these shots. There are some weird cuts, it goes a bit too fast for the song at times, and there are occasional fade in/fade out transitions that don’t really make much sense.

Overall, though, this is a really lovely PV that just happened to be put with a less than lovely song. 7/10

SKE48 – Escape


I tweeted about this which got featured on Idolminded, but I’ll say it again. I am still disappointed that this isn’t a cover of the Pina Colada song.

Song:  This is another cool, electronic song, which fits my image of SKE48 well, especially since they use to make a dance-heavy PV, which is nice.

This is the type of song where, in a different year, I  might find interesting and refreshing. However, in a year where both Kamonegix and Mosh & Dive exist, this is not quite as impressive.

I like the arrangement with keyboard/piano in there, but for the most part it’s not quite as good as it could be. I feel like it could use more bass or a heavier drum beat in back of the higher pitched stuff.

The melody is fine, but a bit basic; in the chorus it mostly rests on one note. It’s not terrible, but it’s not memorable or particularly interesting.

Nitpicking aside, this is a fun track that fits SKE48 very well. I’m just not as enthralled as I could be, given what the 48 groups have put out this past year. The use of the piano ina cool song like this stands out, and I like this song,  but it’s not extraordinary. 6/10

PV: Escape feels like a completely different PV to, say, Party is Over. Here the entire focus is on the dance shot. There are very few shots that don’t involve dancing. And it works. The song is tailored to be more of a dance track, and this is what people are generally going to be interested in, so I’m inclined to be OK with it.

escape1

 

Overall, the dance shot is shot well and edited well. I do think the lighting is a bit too dark and could use more contrast to avoid being just dark, but it felt like they were going for that with the PV. There are sections where there are more lights, so they do play around with it some, but the lighting doesn’t play up any chiaroscuro/exaggerated shadow type things. Which is a bit disappointing, honestly.

escape2 The shots with the keyboard were pretty fun, and basically the only thing breaking up the dancing.

Overall, it’s hard to say too much about this PV because it’s basic. It’s essentially there to service the song and the dance, which it does, but  it’s hardly a remarkable PV by any stretch of the imagination. 6/10

Review Monday: AKB48 – Kimi no Hohoemi wo Yume ni Miru + Mosh & Dive

” Suzukake no ki no michi de “Kimi no hohoemi wo yume ni miru” to itte shimattara bokutachi no kankei wa dou kawatte shimau no ka, boku nari ni nan nichi ka kangaeta ue de no yaya kihazukashii ketsuron no you na mono” is the title of the new AKB48 single. Yeah. So with that out of the way, let’s review the new PVs that have come out! I’ll be reviewing the main single PV as well as Mosh & Dive. Next week I’ll look at the group exclusive PVs.

Suzukake no ki no michi de…..

Song: You know, for being a giant gimmick, I enjoy the long title. I think the sentiment in the title is nice, and while it’s not necessary it’s a pretty title. I’ve been actively trying to memorize it, so I can rattle it off at people in the future for fun.

The title is pretty much the most memorable thing about the song, though. The winter/Janken singles have always been AKB’s least interesting, song-wise, so this isn’t too much of a surprise. However, in a year that started with So Long and Sayonara Crawl, Suzukake stands as one of the more fun songs of the year, if a bit unimpressive.

Of all the songs in AKB’s main single output, this actually reminds me of some of the more rock-inspired stuff. Probably the closest comparisons come to Give Me Five, with a bit of 10nen Zakura. The “suki!” shouts are also straight from Oogoe Diamond. I like this type of song, though; the energetic guitar-based slightly rock-inspired AKB song. Give Me Five isn’t my all-time favorite AKB song, but it’s fun to listen to. I imagine that’s how this song will go down, as well. People will remember the long-title, but when they listen to it they’ll remember that it’s not a bad song at all.

So yeah, in a year where the AKB48 singles haven’t impressed me that much (except for Koisuru Fortune Cookie), this is a good song. It’s not AKB’s finest, but who expects that from the winter/Janken single? 7/10

PV Oh here we go, another long drama version. Honestly, I don’t think this adds a lot to most PVs. It’s an easy thing to advertise; “this comes with a 22-minute PV” but it doesn’t necessarily add much meaning to the PV.

Basically the plot is that in 2003, the members buried a time capsule as students, and this is their reunion 10 years later (which is honestly the plot of the song 10nen Zakura) after they’ve gone separate ways and started new lives.

Going on a bit of a rant here, but long drama versions of PVs for AKB have stopped being interesting or something that’s exciting. No one’s surprised anymore that a single song has a 22 minute PV. Instead, it’s become a crutch for some pretty lazy PV making. You might be wondering how a 22 minute PV, which surely took a lot of time to make, could be considered lazy. Well, what I ask you, is what about this drama PV in particular couldn’t be told within the context of the song, or, at most, with a minute or two of prologue/epilogue? The story isn’t particularly complicated, and it doesn’t even focus on all the members. Instead, they drag out the whole thing across the PV, which lends itself to a not particularly interesting PV in general.

The short version of the PV shows the issues this has. The short version has essentially three types of shots that comprise the majority of the PV.

The main dance shot…

suzukake2

The bad dance shot which they, according to the story, did at school…

suzukake1

Aaaaand close-ups.

suzukake3

 

There are a few past flashbacks and clips of them just standing around, but other than that not much happens. Which isn’t a terrible thing; the first Janken senbatsu PV, Chance no Junban, was a fairly straightforward PV and I think it’s just fine. But when there’s been so much filmed, the fact that none of it gets into this short PV is irritating. They also threw in some hints to the overall story, but nothing that gives it a context.

None of the elements that went into this PV are bad. The dance shot looks fine (I quite like when the members are in silhouette and whenever the background is multicolored), the close-ups look fine. The story is even moving, focusing on Oya Shizuka a lot more than I thought it would. But it just doesn’t have to be in this 22 minute long PV.

Also, you’d think that for a long PV it would focus more on more members. The majority of the screentime is on Jurina, which is understandable. Kitahara Rie, Oya Shizuka, and Oba Mina get some screentime. Kameida Emika gets a speaking part, and Hirata Rina gets a speaking part in English (which is the most delightful part of the PV).

suzukake4

 

But other than that, the members who aren’t immediately popular and recognizable don’t get that much time. I mean, Emika and Hillary don’t get THAT much screentime, and they ranked 2nd and 3rd in the tournament! Usually I don’t rant about the popularity structure in AKB48; for the most part, it generally works. However, the Janken tournament is about giving any member a chance at making it into the AKB48 senbatsu (despite accusations of it being rigged), and this is a bit frustrating. Not entirely unexpected, but frustrating nonetheless.

Ultimately, the pieces of this PV are fine. It’s well put together, like AKB’s PVs generally are. However, putting it into a long form PV when it really should have been shorter ended up hurting it. 6/10

Mosh & Dive (leftover senbatsu)

Song: Initially I’m a bit disappointed; I like AKB’s Christmas songs quite a bit (Yoyaku Shita Christmas is still the best, though) so I was hoping to hear another one!

Disappointments aside, I definitely like Mosh & Dive! It’s a dance track with some good guitar in there, but it feels like a lighter song than something heavy like UZA. A lot of AKB’s “cool” songs (read: the rock-inspired, often dance focused tracks with a lot of guitar) tend to be heavier and darker. Stuff like UZA, Beginner and River are loud and intense. That’s not a terrible thing, but it’s not what I’m always in the mood for. Mosh & Dive goes for a lot lighter singing, an often poppier sound in the chorus, and it generally feels like a lighter cool song. The verses are not quite as good as the chorus, but they’re still pleasant enough.

This is a type of song that I don’t know if I hear a lot of from idol music, but it’s one I’m glad to hear now. I’m not blown away, and I still kind of wish there was a Christmas song on this single, but I’m not disappointed in Mosh & Dive, itself. 8/10.

PV Uh, guys…

moshdive1

What are you even wearing? The short outfits are fine, but those plastic coats? I usually avoid the mosh pit when I go to concerts, but I don’t think that’s what you wear there. Is it to avoid getting beer spilled on you? OK that’s actually a pretty legit excuse.

Questionable outfit choices aside, this is a decent, serviceable PV. All the girls are made up well, especially Minegishi Minami. Something about Miichan’s short hair, that hat, and her makeup make her look fantastic.

moshdive2

While the PV is just a collection of dance shots and close-ups, it’s shot well and lit well. I like how the lighting embraces color in this one, as well as in Kimi no Hohoemi wo Yume wo Miru.

I also like that the PV is shot with a camera that’s moving. It would be easy to do the majority of this with a still camera, but this gives it a really excellent sense of movement.

moshdive3

The only thing I was unsure of with this was the large words thrown on the screen, but I think it fits pretty well. Stylistically it matches the rest of the tone of the PV, and I like that it adds a little bit of flavor to an otherwise standard PV.

Mosh & Dive doesn’t do anything revolutionary, but it’s relatively well-crafted and is a nice, easily enjoyable PV. 6/10

Join me next week as I take a look at the AKB48, SKE48, NMB48 and HKT48 songs/PVs on this single!

Review Monday: NMB48 Team N – Koko ni datte Tenshi wa Iru

Ah, the 48 Stage system. It’s one of my favorite aspects of the 48 empire; the fact that this super popular group performs in a tiny theater. Yet (understandably, given the pace of the 48 Empire lately) the stages have been neglected. The last new stage was over two years ago, and the last new AKB stages were quite a while ago. So when it was announced that a large number of new stages were coming, I was VERY excited.

NMB48’s first original stage for Team N has been a long time coming. It’s been plagued with delays and so many start dates, that I was frankly skeptical that it would ever start. Yet, Team N’s first original stage, Koko ni datte Tenshi wa Iru has been released. So does it live up to the long history and hype?

1. Aoi Tsuki ga Miteru Kara


NMB48 131119 N3 M01 Aoi Tsuki ga Miteru Kara by Cubozoa48

Right away, the song is reminiscent of Dreamin’ Girls, the opener to Boku no Taiyou, the popular stage that was originally a Himawarigumi stage but got recently performed by Team 4 and now Team E. I mean, it’s mostly only reminiscent in that it’s acapella and pretty sounding acapella, but since both are stage openers it came to mind. It’s a good way to open a stage, though, because the vocals sound really nice.

The song then opens up into what only sounds like a victorious, upbeat song. Maybe it’s just me, but it does sound victorious, like “yes, we FINALLY got the original Team N stage out there!” Not sure how intentional this is, but it’s nice. The whole song is well done, and is like a good stage song. It’s not the most memorable song in the world, IMO, but I really enjoy it. It’s pretty, happy, and sounds like a fitting opening. The only thing is that it doesn’t feel like a specifically NMB48 song, but it’s hard to pin down what would be specifically NMB. I like it, though, in the way I love idol-y songs.

The lyrics feel a bit oddly positioned, being the first new stage song in a long time. “Darling darling wait a minute,” no I don’t want to wait a minute, I’m so excited for a brand new stage! “It’s the happiest in the world,” yes, I’m ecstatic to get a new 48 stage and the long awaited Team N stage. It’s probably just a coincidence, but it makes me wonder how much things changed during the course of making the Team N stage, and if this song was positioned at the front specifically because it fits so well.

I also really like these outfits. They’re cute dresses that remind me a bit of the uniforms from NMB Geinin. the only thing I don’t really like on them are the tiny aprons in front; I don’t think they look particularly good.

tenshiiru1

Ultimately, this is a really great way to open a stage. The acapella sounds great, and the whole song is pretty and happy. Off to a good start! 8/10

2. Radio Name


NMB48 131119 N3 M02 Radio Name by Cubozoa48

This song is a mix of beach boys esque pop and ska and I love it. This is a really great, brass-heavy arrangement. I wish there were some more idol songs that sound like this, because I’d love more ska-inspired idol music!

This is unfortunately not QUITE as memorable as Aoi Tsuki ga Miteru Kara, but still very pleasant to listen to. The arrangement is by far the best part about the song, but the rest is fine, too. The lyrics (involving radio as a symbol for romance) remind me a little bit of Heavy Rotation, which makes me want to hear the two of these songs put together.

The one thing that kind of throws me off is that there are shouted parts, which are fine, but they seem to be mixed a bit too loudly in the audio mix of this stage. I wonder if this is something they’ll fix in later shows, because some of those loud “YEAH”s are a bit distracting.

But ultimately, while not quite as memorable, this is a fine song. 7/10

3. Koko ni Datte Tenshi wa Iru


NMB48 131119 N3 M03 Koko ni Datte Tenshi wa Iru by Cubozoa48

For being the title song, this is really not a memorable song, and by far not the song I’ll remember when thinking about this stage. I mean, I suppose there is precedence for this; no one thinks of Renai Kinshi Jourei, but they think of Heart Gata Virus. Theater no Megami is secondary to stuff like Team B Oshi, and Pajama Drive is secondary to stuff like Shonichi. However, you’d think that for your first Team N stage the song would be memorable. Not really.

Koko ni Datte Tenshi wa Iru isn’t a bad song, it’s just a tad on the generic side. The instrumentation reminds me a bit of one of my favorite AKB songs, Yobisute Fantasy, which is also an admittedly fairly idol-y song, but it’s a lot more catchy. Listening to Koko ni Datte isn’t bad, and I find myself enjoying it, but there’s nothing about it that makes me think I’ll ever seek out this song. The song is at that weird mid-tempo point where it’s not quite a ballad but not an upbeat song, and it just feels like it’s dragging even though the song’s only 3 minutes long.

The costumes are very cute, though. I like the fake wings on their back; they could have gone a really gaudy route, but chose to have cute costumes.

tenshiiru1

I really want to say more, but this just feels bland and kind of boring. I have a feeling that NMB fans will want to vote for this at stuff like Request Hour because it’s the titular track on NMB’s first stage, but I really hope they don’t. There are plenty of better songs out there to vote for, and this is just forgettable. And this is coming from someone who loves generic idol pop. 5/10

4. Cattelya no Hana wo Miru Tabi ni Omoidasu


NMB48 131119 N3 M04 Cattleya no Hana wo Miru… by Cubozoa48

This is also a fairly generic idol song, but I like it a lot more than I like Koko ni Datte. I think it’s the little things that make it a step above.

First off, the piano at the beginning is just beautiful. I really wish the song had kept on with this instrumentation for the whole song, because I instantly loved this piano. The rest of the song sounds fine, but that piano had the most impact.

I also think the tempo’s a bit better; it is still a mid-tempo song, but it’s fast enough that it still drives the song forward instead of dragging. There are certain sections, particularly in the chorus, and particularly the back and forth bits, that really drive the whole song forward. They sound nice.

The vocals also sound sweet. This is a very sweet sounding song, which is something I like. It’s delicate and pretty. While this isn’t the image I’d necessarily give NMB48, I really enjoy this song’s presence in this stage. 7/10

5. Yume no Dead Body


NMB48 131119 N3 M05 Yume no dead body by Cubozoa48

OK, let’s get it out of the way, this is the one song title I was like “…well hang on just a sec” about. Definitely one of the odder stage song titles.

In this song Sayanee both plays electric guitar and sings live. Sayanee might not be one of my top 48 idols, and I generally don’t pay much attention to her, but I do have to admit that she’s a definite talent in the group. So I’m glad that they went with a song that fits her well.

This song does fit her well; it’s a cool song that feels like it would be comfortable in the ranks of Bird and Blue Rose as the cool, rock-inspired song of a 48 stage. In fact, since Sayanee has been in the units for Bird AND Blue Rose for the previous two Team N stages, I imagine that’s exactly what they were aiming for. And they totally succeeded.

Sayanee’s voice sounds wonderful with this song, and her guitar playing fits right in. The whole instrumental sounds really good, and the melody is quite catchy. I know I’ll find myself singing “Yume no Dead Bodyyyy” to myself in the days to come.

While I love my cutesy idol songs, there’s certainly a place for the cool, rock idol songs, and this fits right in with the best of them. This fits Sayanee PERFECTLY, and I’m glad they did a great job for NMB’s most popular member. 9/10

6. Nando mo Nerae!


NMB48 131119 N3 M06 Nando mo Nerae! (何度も狙え!) by Cubozoa48

In nearly every stage there’s one song that has the most members, and is generally regarded as the unit that everyone who doesn’t really fit into another unit gets thrown into. It would be easy to make this that song, and I first thought it would be a song like that. However, it’s saved by a performance that is one of the most fun things about this stage.

The song itself is goofy and silly sounding. It’s not fast, but it manages to have a fun, light-hearted feel despite being pretty mid-tempo. After Yume no Dead Body, this is a tone shift in a very major way.

However, the song really is secondary to the performance. The girls manage to instill this with so much personality and energy that I know I’ll want to watch more versions of this song. The girls themselves are what make this great.

This could easily be the least fun unit track of the stage. However, it’s transformed into something to watch. 7/10

7. ONEW no Uwabaki


NMB48 131119 N3 M07 ONEW no Uwabaki by Cubozoa48

I don’t care, Ichikawa Miori totally deserves this center unit. And she really fits this well.

I have a soft spot for the uber-adorable stage songs. I listen to stuff like Tenshi no Shippo and Tonari no Banana a LOT. And while I’m not sure ONEW no Uwabaki is quite on that level of a song for me, this song is certainly cute and enjoyable. The instrumental breaks in particular are adorable.

At first, I wasn’t sure how much I liked the shouts of “O N E W;” on their own they’re fine, but it feels like those don’t quite fit with the song in there. ONEW is a very cutesy, gentle song, and the shouts feel like they’d fit in better with a more energetic styled song. The shouts in the middle of the song feel like they fit better in there, at least.

This song wasn’t my favorite at first, I have to admit. However, after a few listens, it’s grown on me. It’s not the most immediately catchy song, but if you like cutesy songs (like I do) you should like a lot what you hear in ONEW no Uwabaki. 7/10

8. Kono Sekai ga Yuki no Naka ni Umoreru Mae ni


NMB48 131119 N3 M08 Kono Sekai ga Yuki no Naka… by Cubozoa48

Something about the instrumentation at the end makes this song feel like it belongs in the 80s/90s. Not like it’s a bad thing, but it sounds interesting.

This is another song that features live singing, and while there are some off notes for the most part it sounds really good. Kishino Rika’s voice, in particular, sounds excellent. It’s hard to fault some of the off pitch notes, though, because I imagine this will sound a lot better after a few more performances.

The whole thing sounds lovely, and mixing the really solid instrumentation with these nice, live vocals makes the whole song sound great. There’s some good harmonization in there, and it has a bit of an epic feel to it. Really, the pretty vocals are the best thing this song has going for it.

I doubt this is the song I’ll come back to time and again, but it’s really nice and well done. 8/10

9. Zipper


NMB48 131119 N3 M09 Zipper (ジッパー) by Cubozoa48

Fun fact, one of the biggest reasons I didn’t write this review until now is because I couldn’t stop listening to Zipper long enough to actually review the other songs. This is how much I love Zipper.

Full disclosure, I am a big Watanabe Miyuki fan, and this song really fully encapsulates her. For the most part it’s a very cute song that has a bit of a classic idol feel, but there’s a bit of coy sexiness that shows itself once in a while. This is pretty notable in how the instruments are used, particularly in the chorus; sometimes there are parts that sound lush and extravagant in comparison to the rest of the cute song. The whole thing is very catchy, as well, and I’ve found myself singing along to zipper quite a bit since it’s come out.

However, what everyone’s talking about is really the performance, which involves the three girls involved to strip off their outer dresses to some frilly shorts and a small top. The whole performance is very sexy in that kind of coy way, and I think this is done pretty well. It’s not so obviously sexually charged as SDN48’s stage could be at times, but I think it’s better, in a way. I really admire SDN48 for how willing they were to be sexy and out there, when this isn’t something idols are usually allowed to do. However, Zipper really toes that line between cute, typical idol and a sexy image in a way that is totally Milky.

tenshiiru3

This is the type of song I can see people really hating, and I can understand why. Milky is one of those idols who can be pretty polarizing in her approach. However, since I love Milky, I love this. This song is catchy, fun and addicting, and is definitely one of my favorites of this stage. 10/10

10. Hajimete no Hoshi‘


NMB48 131119 N3 M10 Hajimete no Hoshi by Cubozoa48

This song does an interesting thing with its lineup; it returns back to the old Skirt, Hirari and Senaka Kara Dakishimete model of making another unit song for all the popular members. I know some people are a bit stumped, but I like smaller group songs and it’s nice to see the stars of Team N star together. Seven members is a nice size for a lineup, and all of these girls feel like they’re well suited to the song and standing up in that top 7 of Team N.

tenshiiru4

I like this song. It sounds like a lot of other stage songs, but it has a good pace to it. The arrangement is quite good, too; the guitar in particular sounds quite nice. Vocally, Sayanee sounds REALLY great in here! This stage is really reminding me that I don’t pay enough attention to Sayanee as a singer, nor do I give her enough credit. Everyone sounds pretty good here, but Sayanee’s voice really stands out.

The lyrics are also quite nice, making this another song about working hard and aiming for dreams. This is the type of theme that, despite getting used in 48 song after 48 song, I haven’t managed to get tired of. The whole song feels like it fits these lyrics, too. It doesn’t have the power of Pioneer or emotion of Shonichi, but this is a worthy entry in the collection of ’48 songs about reaching for your dreams.’

The dancing also has a lot of energy to it; it feels like a forceful, strong dance, and all the members do well with it. I normally don’t review much choreography because I wouldn’t really know what to say, but this choreography is quite nice.

So while it’s not quite as much of a showstopper as Shonichi, it’s still a good song and a nice addition to this stage. 8/10

11. 100nen Saki Demo


NMB48 131119 N3 M11 100nen Saki Demo by Cubozoa48

Why hello there, electronic beat with a slightly disco feel. When I first started listening to this I knew that this was going to be something I will enjoy. And I do enjoy this. This is one of the closest songs in the stage to the current style that NMB has been doing in their singles, at least with Kamonegix.

This isn’t quite as disco-y as I wanted to be, but the cool, electronic feel feels more like NMB48 than a lot of the earlier songs. The change in key between the verses and chorus sounds a bit unusual, but I really like it; it’s a unique sound.

The song works well with the lyrics, which are basically about eternal, destined love. I hate using the term epic in my descriptions because the word is VERY overused, but it fits here. This is the story of an epic romance, and the song has that feel.

This is one of my favorite songs in the stage so far. Even though Hajimete no Hoshi seems to be trying for that showstopper type of song, 100nen Saki Demo is really appealing. 9/10

12. Ribbon Nante Niawanai


NMB48 131119 N3 M12 Ribbon Nante Niawanai by Cubozoa48

The first thing this title reminded me of was the Watarirouka Hashiritai 7 song “Bikini wa Niawanai,” and bits of the opening remind me of that song so I guess I’m not that far off? There’s a little bit of the Beach style pop that’s in Bikini wa Niawanai in here, though not to that degree.

That’s where the similarities end, though, because Ribbon Nante Niawanai is an upbeat classic idoly song. It feels like such a cutesy, classic idol song, much more cutesy and classic than NMB48 really has ever felt for me. Even though the song is about figuring out which style suits you, especially in that process of growing up, I don’t think this song suits NMB48 very much, even when they do their cuter songs.

The song itself is pretty fun and catchy, though, and is certainly not bad. The performance is cute, too, featuring pom poms. This just feels a bit too generic and like it doesn’t suit NMB48 much. I feel like that’s a solid criticism for a lot of the songs in this, really. Even though NMB48 often does cuter songs (Mattemashite Shingakki, Boku wa Mou Sukoshi Daitan Nara, Mousou Girlfriend, etc.) this just doesn’t feel like it suits NMB48. Which is a bit of a shame, given this is NMB’s first original stage.

I have a feeling this song will grow on me, and I wonder if subsequent performances and viewings will have me changing my tune a bit. I just can’t see this being one of NMB’s big representative songs, is all I’m saying. 6/10

13. Degas to Ballerina


NMB48 131119 N3 M13 Doga to Ballerina by Cubozoa48

Oh hey art reference I get! Degas was a very famous painter, who notably painted ballerinas. So that’s where Degas came from.

Normally slower songs bore me. It’s not necessarily the fact that they’re slow paced ballads, but I just don’t think a lot of them are done in a very interesting way. I really enjoy this song, though. Despite being slower it doesn’t drag and it has a nice pace. Arrangement wise, the organ and piano sounds are really lovely. Most of the vocals sound great, especially in the verses, but the pitch gets a little too high in the chorus for some, which makes the vocals sound like they’re straining a bit.

The performance is nice, as well, with a lot of ballet inspired moves. There’s even a bit of ballet dancing in there, though I think it looks a bit awkward in those shoes. Still, it is a nice touch.

tenshiiru6

Aside from some strained vocals, this is a really pretty song. Perhaps because of those vocals, I tend to like the vocals a lot more. Still, for not being a ballad person, I really enjoy this. 8/10

14. Jounetsu Highway


NMB48 131119 N3 M14 Jonetsu Highway by Cubozoa48

Holy neon costumes batman! These certainly are interesting. The design isn’t bad, but the color choices made me pause for a bit.

tenshiiru8

This is one of the most fun, happy songs of the stage. It’s full of energy and is a joy, especially after the slow (but pretty) Degas to Ballerina. The song is very much aiming to be a rock song, including shouts of “rock and roll!” and even “twist and shout!” in there. It works, though; this song got me in a good mood!

Perhaps in the grand scheme of things this isn’t THE most original sound ever, but it’s a breath of fresh air in this stage. I’ve enjoyed most of the stage so far, don’t get me wrong, but this is exactly the song that the stage needed at this time. It feels very well positioned, which is really nice.

This song is fun, peppy, and just what the stage needed at the time. 7/10

15. Sukoshi Nigai Jinsei Soudan


NMB48 131119 N3 M15 Sukoshi Nigai Jinsei Soudan by Cubozoa48

Since the title involves the words “slightly bitter” I was worried this song would get too angry or sad; however, this does a really good job of being both upbeat but emotional. It’s not the most emotional song out there, mind you, but it has a definite amount of feeling to it. I like how the first verse starts off sounding like a pretty typical ballad before exploding into electric guitar sound. Very cool.

I don’t know if I quite like this as much as I want to like it. It’s a fine song, I like the lyrics, and I like what it’s trying to do. It just doesn’t sound quite as interesting as it possibly SHOULD, given it’s placement as second song in the encore. Perhaps this is because this gives me expectations that are too high; the second song in the chorus is home to stuff like Pioneer and Team B Oshi.

This is a good song, though, and I especially like the moments when it treads the line between ballad and upbeat guitar-heavy song. These moments of transition are the most fun in the song. It’s a generally pleasant, easy to listen to song. 6/10.

16. Fumo no Tochi wo Mankai ni


NMB48 131119 N3 M16 Fumo no Tochi wo Mankai ni by Cubozoa48

While Hajimete no Hoshi was the “look at how hard we’ve worked” song, Fumo no Tochi wo Mankai ni is the “NMB48 song.” The lyrics literally go “NMB here we are.” This is a declaration. While I’d dispute some of the lyrics (seriously, WHO said ‘flowers can’t bloom here?’ I don’t think anyone said “you can’t have idols in Osaka).

Again, this really doesn’t give as much of a punch as it really should. For being supposed to be a strong declaration of “here we are” the only parts where they sound like they mean that are the “NMB here we are” sections and possibly the chorus. The verse really doesn’t have the impression of being NMB48 saying “here we are.” Using Pioneer as a template, this doesn’t quite declare NMB’s strengths as a group, nor does it quite deliver in the way it intends.

This isn’t a bad song, by any means, but it doesn’t live up to what it’s trying for. 6/10

17. NMB Medley


NMB48 131119 N3 M17 Medley (メドレー) by Cubozoa48

I’m not going to review this thoroughly, because none of these songs are new, but I generally enjoy all of them.

Highlights:
Aoi Tsuki ga Miteru Kara
Zipper
100nen Saki Demo

Overall: This is a solid stage that has some excellent moments. I don’t think it will end up being a particular favorite stage like B3 is to me, but it’s certainly not bad, and the good parts certainly justify the so-so parts.

Review Monday: Shiritsu Ebisu Chuugaku – Mikakunin Chuugakusei X

So my goal for today was to review the new Team N stage (which I will end up reviewing for next Monday). However, I had a fairly long day, so I decided to review the new PV by Shiritsu Ebisu Chuugaku. Which I’ve been meaning to review for some time because, spoiler, it’s pretty great.

Song: I’m a sucker for high energy songs. Which is why, even if I’m not necessarily as big on Shiritsu Ebisu Chuugaku as, say, Team Syachihoko, I generally appreciate Ebichu’s music. If you want something high energy, this is a strong bet. The melody is immediately catchy and a total earworm, which works well with the electronic instrumentation the song goes for. I’ve spent a bit of time singing “zukkyun zukkyun” to myself. I really like the sections where the song slows down. This is where the arrangement is at its best and it allows the girls to emote more than they could. Really, though, this entire song is catchy and fun and exactly what you’d want from a song that’s called “Unidentified middle school students X.” It’s wacky and fits well into Ebichu’s discography.

Perhaps this is me being too much of a Hyadain fangirl, but there were parts that made me wish he had a hand in writing this. The Hyadain influences are palpable, especially the occasional drastic tempo changes. Hyadain is a frequent Ebichu collaborator (including the B-Side to this track, ‘I’m your MANAGER!!’) and I wish he would have just arranged this. The arrangement isn’t bad; in fact, I like it most of the time. I enjoy the fairly heavy, almost techno beat in there. The only thing I really wish would change is that I wish there was a bit of a heavier beat and just more to the arrangement in the chorus section, which feels occasionally empty. But, thinking of Hyadain’s work arranging Dempagumi.inc’s Not Bocchi…Natsu, he turned what was already a great song into a fantastic song that’s one of the group’s best. That’s what I feel like he could have done here. Mikakunin is wonderful, and great, but I feel like it just needs one more push to being that group-defining song I feel it could be.

I don’t want to sound like I’m too critical of the song. This is a great song, and definitely worth your time (especially if you enjoy high energy idol pop). However, it’s that type of song that COULD be a group-defining song, and I kind of wish that they had figured it out. That said, while I do think it could improve, this is still a great song. 8/10.

PV: So, uh, I have a bit of an affinity for bad movies. I don’t go out of my way to enjoy them, but let’s just say I’ve seen Birdemic: Shock and Terror multiple times. Willingly. So when I first started to play the PV and there was (poorly done) written text against a “space” backdrop, I knew I was in for a treat.

mikakunin1

 

I love all the “effects” in this PV. You can tell they made it poorly on purpose, from everything being clearly made out of cardboard, to the “alien” being a guy with a paper hat and cardboard claws. And the alien is basically just a mantis guy. OK Ebichu, whatever you say.

mikakunin2 mikakunin3

I have to say, on another sidenote about lighting, H!P this is how you do mood lighting. There is a lot of darkness in this early story section, but it’s used for “dramatic” effect. I know that this is meant to be a cheesy scene, but they actually did a good job of making it look interesting. So good job, Ebichu director!

mikakunin4

 

The story itself is understandably silly, but they do a good job of selling it. The best thing they do is that they do what “good” bad movies do, which is take themselves seriously. The most enjoyable bad movies are the ones where the director or whoever else is the main driving force behind the movie takes the project seriously. That’s why movies like The Room and Birdemic are so entertaining. The whole thing is silly, but the actors appear to give it their all, which is nice.

mikakunin5

 

mikakunin6

 

Ebichu themselves don’t get to ham it up as much as the extras, but they have their fun, posing and being the heroes of the story, the Mikakunin Chuugakusei X. Unfortunately, this makes them not quite as memorable as the other actors in the PV (which is a bit of a shame, given that they’re, you know, the stars). They get to make funny faces and face off against the evil mantis people, but they have a lot of shots just hanging out in the library. Which would be fine in most other PVs, but I wish they’d had a bit more interesting things to do to make the group itself stand out in this memorable PV.

mikakunin7

 

mikakunin9

 

The biggest thing that I have to wonder is why half of the dance shot takes place outside. I mean, it doesn’t look BAD, but it doesn’t make too much sense. The other half takes place in the library, which is a solid choice. I just think it would have been interesting to see part of the dance shot take place on the stage where they face off against the mantis people. The lighting is cool, and it makes sense that Ebichu would perform there, since it’s a stage. The dance shot is at its best, though, at the end where they do the dance with all sorts of back dancers. I’m a sucker for that type of thing, and Ebichu does it well.

mikakunin8 mikakunin10But really, aside from some creative choices that made me scratch my head, this is one of the most entertaining and fun PVs of the year. 9/10.

Overall: Even though I’m nitpicking this a bit, this is really a very strong song and PV, and is very much worth your time.

 

Review Monday: Juice=Juice “Ijiwaru Shinaide Dakishimete yo”

Happy Review Monday! Today’s topic: the new Juice=Juice PV!

Juice=Juice – Ijiwaru Shinaide Dakishimete yo

Song: This is the most old-school H!P song I’ve heard in a while. This instantly made me think of stuff like Kiiroi Osora de Boom Boom Boom and Gatamekira. As a fan of H!P’s old-school sound (especially of stuff like T&C Bomber/Taiyou to Ciscomoon), this is a great sound that I want more of in H!P. I’ve really enjoyed the releases from Juice=Juice (especially Watashi ga Iu Mae ni Dakishimenakya and Romance no Tochuu) and Ijiwaru Shinaide Dakishimete yo continues with that musical excellence. This does a great job of being consistent with previous releases (it sounds like a Juice=Juice song should sound like) while also being distinct. It’s catchy and fun.

As always, Juice=Juice has some of the best arrangement in H!P. The piano sections in particular stand out. Not quite as much as the saxophone in their first single, mind you, but I don’t think much will. The lovely piano bits are part of a really solid whole, however; the rest of the arrangement is really nice. Occasionally the background vocals sound a bit too loud, but that could be because I want to hear more of Juice=Juice. Tomoko and Sayubee in particular sound great, but the rest of the girls sound very good. So there’s really no need for overwhelming background vocals unlike, say, early Berryz Koubou. The arrangement strikes a good balance; the girls’ voices are rarely overwhelmed but it doesn’t sound empty like some Hello!Project songs are guilty of.

Aside from the mixing issue of making the background vocals a bit too loud (at least to my taste) this is a well-produced song that continues Juice=Juice’s excellent streak of singles.

PV: Dear Up-Front/Hello!Project,

You can continue putting Ishida Ayumi in everything. I wholeheartedly approve.

Signed, Serenyty

Seriously, though, even though pretty much everyone was skeptical about it, Ayumi fits in very well with Juice=Juice.

ijuwaru1

The situation is still a bit awkward, and I imagine that there was extensive discussion on what to do with Karin’s foot injury. However, I think this ended up being a good choice (it’s hard to imagine only four people doing this dance) and Ayumi fits in really well visually and with her dance skills. My friend Dani pointed out that this is a good case for more shuffles, and I agree. The Satoyama/Satoumi units are fine, but I’d love proper summer shuffles again where all of H!P’s shuffled up.

That said, it is a bit strange seeing Karin in part of the PV and Ayumi in the other. It also doesn’t hurt that this isn’t a very interesting PV. There are two sets of close up shots, occasional group shots and the dance shot. It’s very basic and on a basic set.

ijiwaru2

 

I like this a lot in theory. The dark background and the red floor is a cool idea. But the way it was executed makes it look kind of boring and empty. Like they just set up walls and a floor and were like “let’s call it a day!” (which, let’s be real, is probably what they did).

ijiwaru3

 

These sets looked a lot cooler, IMO. Some mirrors, some beads on strings, and it already looks cooler. I like how they emphasized the members’ colors with the lighting but made it fairly subtle. Though every time they had Tomoko sing “I am rose-quartz” I swear she gives the camera this look like “yeah I know why they gave me this line.”

ijiwaru4

 

Those sets are well-lit and nice. The rest of the PV’s lighting is not that great. One of the biggest complaints I’ve seen about this PV is that it’s dark looking. My response is that dark isn’t bad; it’s just the same old boring flat lighting that most H!P PVs are lit at. Look at that screencap up there with Tomoko; she has shadow to her face which adds dimension, and there’s a good contrast between her face and the background. It looks nice. Then let’s look at this screencap with Akari.

ijiwaru5

 

See how little shadow there is on her face? There are tiny amounts of darkness, but for the most part this is completely flat lighting, which means that the light is diffused over the whole thing. Now for the most part you don’t want a ton of shadows unless you want a specific mood (like in The X-Files; some scenes are basically in the dark). However, some shadows add depth, character to a face. Akari’s face here looks like it’s not brightly lit AND it’s super flat, which just makes it look worse.

While a lot of the issues are with the actual lighting setup, they could have done more in the post-production. I took that same screenshot and did a little bit of editing in my freeware photo editor.

ijiwaru6

 

I slightly upped the brightness and I raised the contrast. This looks a lot more dynamic than the flat image presented earlier. Of course, the editing on the video would have had to do just that; upping the contrast on a moving image. However, this took me about 10 seconds to do.

There are even scenes where it’s too bright. I know they wanted to do a lens flare type effect or SOMETHING, but seriously, what were they attempting with this?

ijuwaru7

 

That said, not every shot has awful lighting, so points for that?

ijiwaru8

 

I think this has a lot of potential. I really enjoy the song, the general aesthetic feel of the PV, and the costumes are nice. H!P just didn’t take the time to take this PV further, to make it better. Which is frustrating.

Overall: This is a really nice song, and a decent but extremely flawed PV.

Review Monday: Sukeban Deka: Codename = Asamiya Saki

One of the things I don’t talk about too much on this blog is that, while I talk a lot about music and the music industry, my real expertise is in the area of film. I was a Film/TV/Media studies student in college, and while I haven’t had a chance to use this (yet), I tend to focus on music on this blog.

However, when thinking of things to review for Mondays, I had an idea. And that was…

Sukeban Deka: Codename = Asamiya Saki

Background Knowledge: While I think that films should have to stand on their own, a little bit of the background can be interesting. Sukeban Deka was a fairly long running manga series. Asamiya Saki was delinquent high school student who starts to work for the police, investigating/fighting crime in high schools with her weapon as a metal yo-yo.

The series has since been adapted into multiple TV shows and movies, usually starring a popular idol as Saki. The first Saki, Saito Yuki, comes back into this movie as Saki’s mother. So this is a series with a lot of history that got resurrected, starring solo idol Matsuura Aya and also featuring Ishikawa Rika (and the rest of v-u-den) from Hello!Project.

Review:  One of my favorite film reviewers was the late Roger Ebert. Now I know this is kind of a stereotypical answer; he happens to be the most famous film critic. However, the reason I really loved reading Ebert’s reviews is because he took into account questions of genre and intent. Not every film aspires to be high art, and not every film can be Citizen Kane. Ebert was aware of this, and took it into account when writing his reviews.

The reason I started off with this is because Sukeban Deka is the type of movie that you know what you’re getting when you go into the movie. The American title is “Yo-Yo Girl Cop” (which might just win the title for “most phoned in movie title,” but it gets the job done). When I bought this movie on DVD (yes, I own a physical copy) I knew I wanted exactly three things.

1. Badass Matsuura Aya

2. Badass Ishikawa Rika

3. Badass Yo-yo fighting.

I mean, I hoped that there would be a half-decent story, that the cinematography wouldn’t suck and that the acting wouldn’t be terrible. But this is the type of movie where that type of thing is not quite as necessary to my enjoyment. This doesn’t mean my standards are low, it just means that I have expectations as to what type of film this is. This is a fairly cheesy action movie, and that’s what I want from it.

Story: For being a story about a girl in a high school outfit wielding a yoyo as a weapon, the film takes itself surprisingly seriously. The plot hinges around Saki going undercover in a high school. She has 72 hours to uncover the meaning of a countdown on a website promoting illicit activity, and if she does so she’ll save her mother. Really, the entire storyline featuring Saki and her mother is the best part of the movie.

The rest of the storyline isn’t perfect but is serviceable. The only explanation for the high school being such a terrible place where you’re allowed to assault other students is “adults are useless,” which was obviously a way to lampshade that most high schools aren’t hellholes in the way this movie would like us to believe.

The overall theme of bullying and depression works, and I think they did it fine. They gave concepts like suicidal thoughts and self-harm the gravity they deserve. However, certain bits detract from the story. The whole storyline between Yui and Erika, while sweet at times, feels cliched when they adopt the names of Juliet and Romeo, respectively. I also didn’t like how the new Romeo, the main person behind the site, is somehow this enthralling person for no apparent reason. This felt forced, and frankly uninteresting.

The tone of the movie varies a lot. On the one hand it’s trying to be serious, and on the other hand there are silly sound effects when Saki opens her eyes and there is some (albeit poor) comic relief with the chemistry club. The movie wants to take itself seriously, but is often held back. It would be possible (though hard) to do this completely straight and serious and it would be possible to make it a giant camp fest, but making it a bit in the middle hurts the film overall.

I also wish the pacing was slightly different. I get that they wanted to impose an arbitrary time limit to add tension, but it feels kind of rushed. One minute Aya is bloodied and running from the cops, the next she’s getting a school uniform and her yoyo, the next she’s chasing down a kid with a bomb and throwing a yoyo (albeit imperfectly). The movie also drags a lot in the middle when they’re explaining the origins of the Enola Gay website. There’s a surprising lack of yoyo fighting.

All in all, the story is mostly serviceable, but certain parts drag the whole thing down and end up being uninteresting. A little better pacing, give it more in the way of action, either make it more serious or more cheesy, and it would be a lot better. The movie is at it’s best when it’s centering on Saki vs Reika (Rika’s character), Saki comforting Tae (Okada Yui), and Saki thinking on her mother. If the movie had focused more on Saki’s growth as a character and focused on these things, it would have been a much better movie.

Acting: You know, for being two novice actresses (unless you count blatant H!P stuff like Hello!Morning), Ayaya and Rika do a really great job. They both throw themselves into their roles. Matsuura Aya isn’t what I would classify as badass, but she makes a believable delinquent, and I root for her. She plays a good stoic character and quickly I forget that this is Ayaya, the charismatic idol singer. Rika does a fatnastic job too, balancing fake smiles with cold glares. In her first scene, when she and Aya first meet, there is one shot where her smile slowly turns into a glare. She does a very good job, and it’s no wonder that Rika’s had a good amount of acting in her post Hello!Project career.

Unfortunately, the acting beyond Ayaya and Rika is a bit iffy. Okada Yui and Miyoshi Erika do decent jobs, but don’t quite deliver on the emotional resonance that they’re meant to. Okada in particular; she’s the character we’re really supposed to feel for, but she doesn’t quite deliver emotionally. Her acting doesn’t feel natural. Erika is in the movie much less and does a whole lot less and does a fine enough job for what she has, but isn’t a particularly talented actress.

The rest of the actors range from poor to acceptable. I don’t particularly care for the guy who plays Jiro, the new Romeo, who hardly seems like the charismatic ringleader that the movie makes him out to be. The rest of the actors are fine, though often erring on the side of cheesiness.

Cinematography/Editing/Aesthetics: One of the first things I noticed is that the title sequence is really pleasant. It’s simple, but the use of the silhouettes of Saki/Ayaya look quite nice.

From then on out the film looks fine, but nothing to really write home about. The one thing that really grabs my notice is just how dark and depressing this movie looks. The lighting is drab, and it’s rare that this movie is bright. I wish they had used the lighting a bit better; for the most part the lighting is pretty flat; even in the darkness, there’s no real sense of light and shadow. It makes the movie feel kind of bleak and dismal, which I assume is what they were going for, but the movie could have done better with some more dramatic lighting.

There are a few lovely shots; the contrast of Aya, with a red umbrella in a sea of white, comes to mind. Nothing in this movie looks particularly terrible, except for some of the special effects. But nothing stands out that much.

The one thing that bugs me the most is some of the shots do weird things. There are fast zooms and pans over to things (with an accompanying sound effect) and lots of fast paced editing. But among all that fast editing there is some weird slow motion bits that don’t really justify being in slow motion and occasionally some still frames that just distract. For the most part the cinematography is serviceable and adequate, but these moments detract from even that.

Audio: The main audio concerns are the two songs by GAM; Shinkirou Romance (featured in the film itself) and Thanks! (in the credits). I’ve always liked GAM as a unit, and both of these songs are quite good. I kind of wonder why they went for a unit as opposed to doing two songs by Aya as a soloist, but if this movie gave me GAM then I’m not complaining.

Shinkirou Romance  is a good song, but feels a bit out of place. It’s a bit too loud, and doesn’t quite fit the scene. I feel like they wanted to get the song in the movie but they just ended up forcing it, hurting the movie. Why else would they stop the movie to a halt to have Aya and Yui looking at their phones for a good section of the song?

Other than that, the background music is fine but not extraordinary. Some of the sound effects are a bit exaggerated and a bit much, but for the most part they’re fine.

Overall: This is a pretty solid movie. Some of the aspects are a lot better than expected, some are just weird (just how slow the movie can get in places) and some are regretable. I think there’s potential in here for a better movie. However, that said, this movie can be a lot of fun, and it’s one that I enjoy watching. 6.5/10

Review Monday: Morning Musume – What is Love?

I was kind of racking my brain for what I could review for this week’s Review Monday post. The problem is, not much has come out recently that I really need to say something about. I considered Juice=Juice’s new PV, but I have nothing much to say other than “I kind of like this.” AKB48’s latest came out recently, but even that’s a bit of a letdown after the fantastic Koisuru Fortune Cookie. Then my friend Dani suggested I take a look at Morning Musume’s newest song “What is Love?” It hasn’t been released yet, and there’s not even a plan for its release yet, but I thought this was an excellent idea.

Oh wait, no, wrong clip (sorry, I know this joke is so old by now).

Song: I’ve been really into this song since the first short preview popped up online, and if this gets put on a single it will potentially be my favorite Morning Musume song of the year. That’s how much I like this.

One of the things common to a lot of my favorite songs is that they bend genres. I’m a fan of groups like Babymetal and Rhymeberry because they aren’t afraid to do something unusual with their music, and to mesh an unusual genre with idol music. Morning Musume does this almost perfectly with “What is Love.” They take the current electronic/dubstep-lite sound that Morning Musume has been doing for their last few singles and mixed it with, of all things, 1920s era swing/jazz. This is the type of thing that doesn’t get mixed with current music a lot. If modern music decides to look back, they usually stick to the 50s onward. But here, Morning Musume is taking on a genre and era of music, mixing it with some very modern sounds, and doing something very unique.

There is a bit of risk to doing this song; if this was done poorly, it would have been just awful. That’s generally why Hello!Project acts tend to keep it safe, musically. However, Morning Musume does this unusual mix very well here. The swing music mixes remarkably well with the electronic music and, apart from the initial shock of hearing two separate genres combined, doesn’t sound forced or like a bad combination. The song itself is very catchy and the arrangement fits well. I normally prefer real instruments, but the type of song fits this type of arrangment.

Basically, I love this song on multiple levels. It’s very listenable and catchy, but I also love what it represents, bending genres. Morning Musume has been on a roll with solid releases lately (even though I didn’t enjoy their remix album), and I’m very impressed by what they’ve done with What is Love. 9/10

Dance: Since there’s no PV, I’ll just give a few quick words about the dance. Dance is probably the area I know least about with idols. However, Morning Musume’s dances have stood out a lot lately, and this is no exception. I know to some the dance formations are getting a bit old, but that’s one of the aspects I love about current Morning Musume. The dances all look a thousand times cooler and more interesting when all the members are moving together in a formation.

Some people think this dance is too weird. It is a bit odd, at times, but ultimately it fits really well with both the style of music they’re doing as well as the current style Morning Musume has right now. I especially like the part during the chorus where the girls swing their leg in front and in back of them. Ultimately, as a complete non-expert on dance, I really like this. It’s unusual, but I like unusual.

Verdict: This song and dance are great. While I’ve had my misgivings with MM releases in the past, Morning Musume does an excellent job with What is Love. 9/10

Review Monday: Momoiro Clover Z – GOUNN

I was wondering what to do with the Review Monday segment this week, when I saw the PV release for Momoiro Clover Z’s single “GOUNN.” Since this is actually the first single from MomoClo this year, it’s a very highly anticipated single and music video that’s been hyped up for quite some time.

The Song: I’ve made it no secret that Momoiro Clover’s music has had its ups and downs for me. While a lot of their older music is some of my favorite idol music, their current music has been a mixed bag for me. However, this is the strongest MomoClo has been musically in a while, aside from some of the better tracks on 5th Dimension.

The song itself is quite good, and memorable. The song was written by Shihori, a Japanese singer songwriter who I do not believe has written for any idol acts. I have to believe that, after GOUNN, idol acts are going to be knocking on her door, because this is wonderful. I don’t know if I fully appreciated the song during my first listen, but it is an earworm after a good few listens. The girls in Momoiro Clover Z sound great, too, and while a large part of that is undoubtedly due to practice and good vocal direction, the song fits their vocals well. Kanako in particular sounds really nice, especially for being a fairly weak singer. For this single, MomoClo were going for a “Buddhism” theme (something I’ll delve into a bit later), and while it would be easy to go full stereotype, Shihori gets a bit of that kind of flavor into the song without making it sound like it’s from a bad stereotype of Indian people.

Probably my biggest rant about Momoiro Clover Z was my reaction to Otome Sensou. It was the first MomoClo single I genuinely did not like, and while parts of that song have since grown on me, I still have a lot of complaints. One of these complaints is that the arrangement was weak. This song completely avoids that. The instrumentation is lush and full, fitting the song, but never really feeling busy. The slow moments, featuring piano, are lovely, and I love pretty much all the bass lines thrown in there. There’s a bit that sounds like an electric sitar, but don’t hold me to that. But it sounds really nice, and fits with the song without making it sound stereotype-y.

Most importantly, the song just works. There are wonderful individual elements, but they all work nicely together. Otome Sensou is a song where I can see how I would want to change the song. While there are other songs I like better this year, this is the best GOUNN that they could possibly make. So I’m very happy for MomoClo. 8/10.

PV: OK, I’m going to get this out of the way, since I’ve been working on putting this in words for a while, and doing some research. I’m not quite sure how I feel about this PV, cultural sensitivity wise. First off, I’m going to have a disclaimer: I am not an expert in Buddhism, Hinduism, Shinto, or any religion that isn’t Judeo-Christian or Greek/Roman mythology. So I’m not making any conclusions about this PV. If anyone is particularly versed in Buddhism (particularly Mahayana, which is what is mostly practiced in Japan), Hinduism or Shinto, please feel free to comment.

That said, I did have initial misgivings, especially due to the costumes. Even if everything is completely accurate or is as close to accurate as possible, it is still taking aesthetics from popular belief systems that people do think should be handled with weight. The idea that this kind of aesthetic, taken from these religions/belief systems, is somehow used as MomoClo’s new PV aeshetic bothered me. I don’t practice these religions, and I know that Japan isn’t a very religious nation itself, but it’s an issue of respect. This is also added to the unfortunate fact that MomoClo doesn’t have the best track record for cultural sensitivity in their music videos.

That said, I am a bit confused with the religion portrayed in the PV. MomoClo has called it “Buddhism-themed,” which would make sense. Buddhism spread to Japan, and is one of the more significant religions in Japanese history. However, certain things made me suspect that this wasn’t as accurate to Buddhism as it could be.

gounn1

 

This depicts a turtle on top of a serpent, with elephants on top of it. This is a big part of Hindu mythology, in which the Earth is balanced on top of elephants balanced on a turtle balanced on a serpent. This is a fairly well-known aspect of that religion. However, I was unable to find any references of this myth in relation to Buddhism.

Buddhism is a system of beliefs that is sometimes debated on whether or not it’s a religion, primarily because worship of deities isn’t a major part of said religion. Enlightenment is the primary goal of Buddhism, not closeness to a god or gods. That said, worship of deities does occur in Mahayana Buddhism, which is what spread to Japan. I’ve been trying to look up who each member was supposed to be. I believe Kanako is approximating the Medicine Buddha, but I’m not sure.

gounn2

 

The costumes are the last thing that make me wait and consider. They look to be more approximations of Shinto goddesses rather than anything else. Which adds to the whole giant mixed  up PV this is.

Like I said earlier, I don’t want to make any conclusions. I don’t think MomoClo are trying to do something bad, and I’m not even sure if I think this is all that bad. BUT It does make me sit up and wonder. If you or someone you know is an expert in this field, I’d like to hear from you.

All of that aside, I really like this PV a lot.

gounn3

THIS is how you do a highly visual effects driven PV. None of the effects look cheap or goofy at all; instead, they work to create a very visually pleasing PV that looks incredible. MomoClo has all been lit well and shot well, so the effects work well to create a visually stunning PV. This is possibly the best looking PV that I’ve ever seen done primarily using visual effects.

gounn4

 

The sections where it’s just MomoClo in these circles, adding to visual patterns. It looks great, and is a bit of a gutsy move, just based on being able to show very small pictures of the girls to go along with the visuals.

gounn5Some people may be taken aback by how unusual this PV is, which is a big part of why I want to figure out more of the religious backing to the PV. For example, Ayaka here is sitting on a tongue, surrounded by teeth, holding a toothbrush. Kanako is holding a syringe and surrounded by blood. Reni is sitting on and surrounded by hair. The PV is so beautiful, though, that it’s hard to catch until someone goes “oh my god that’s teeth in the background” (which is admittedly what happened to me, when someone pointed that in a Facebook group I frequent).

The editing, while good, isn’t perfect. There are points where it feels too fast and frantic; more than once it edits exactly on the sung syllables (when Ayaka sings “ka-ru-ma,” there’s an edit on each one of those syllables). However, this is a small complaint. I do wish that the girls were doing a bit more. They take part in the dance shot, they appear in the visuals I showed above, but for the most part they’re just sitting in their location. This is fine, and I’d imagine things were limited by the visual effects. However, that is a bit of a disappointment.

Ultimately, though, this is a visually stunning PV, and while I was taken aback by some of the PV’s content, that doesn’t change that this a well put together PV. 8/10.

 

Review Monday: C-ute’s Tokai no Hitorigurashi + Ai tte Motto Zanshin

C-ute is a group I’ve followed occasionally, and I’ve even bought some Maimi goods, but I don’t know if I would consider myself a big fan of theirs. Nothing wrong with C-ute, mind you, but I really don’t pay attention to them as much as other groups. However, their career has had a really interesting trajectory. Starting off as the ‘leftover group’ from the H!P Kids, C-ute has grown to surpass the original H!P Kids group Berryz Koubou, and has lately gotten even more recognition. They’ve gone from a group that did Ooki na Ai de Motenashite to a group that does more adult things like Crazy Kanzen na Otona. So how does their new single hold up?

Tokai no Hitorigurashi

Song: This song had to grow on me. I definitely liked it at first, but it’s not immediately catchy. The best word I can use to describe this song is pleasant. There isn’t anything immediately interesting about the song or anything mind-blowing about it, but I do like the song. The chorus is a lot more interesting than the verses (especially the repeated “Why Not” sections), but the verses grew on me too.

My biggest complaint is the arrangement. It’s a nice sounding instrumental track, but the electronic backing doesn’t fit as well. If they had used real instruments (I’m thinking this would be brass heavy, but would have some piano and strings in there), the song would sound a lot nicer. This isn’t an electronic song like some of Morning Musume’s latest fare; those songs make sense to have mostly electronic stuff going on. This is not the same type of song, and the instrumental is just disappointing. I like the melody and song enough that that would make this transcend from being just good to really great.

The lyrics are nice; Tsunku isn’t a master lyricist or anything but they aren’t bad. The only thing that made me pause was the line about being chubby. Um, no one in C-ute is even remotely chubby.

Nice and pleasant are the ultimate words I will use in reference to this song. I like it a lot better than some of the recent stuff C-ute has done, but it’s not going to be on my top song list of the year or anything.

PV: PVs are not H!P’s forte. It’s gotten to the point where, if H!P has a PV that’s even remotely good or interesting, I’ll be excited and happy for them. I have to think this is where this PV stands. If you are comparing it to all idol groups, it’s not the most interesting of PVs. However, compared to H!P, this is wonderful.

tokai1

 

The biggest thing I admire about this PV is its unified aesthetic choice. It’s doing this style which feels unique and fresh, but also appealing. This goes a long way for turning a PV from boring and average to being interesting.

tokai2

 

The best part are the member introductions at the beginning. They’re designed well, all the girls look nice, and it has a really dynamic feel to it. I think a good part of that is because the girls move into the still shots of them, instead of just featuring the still shots. There’s a lot of motion in this PV, which I always like.

tokai3

 

One of the things that’s hard to show in the screencaps is that there is a fairly long, single take shot on what looks to be a handheld camera (or at least not a steadycam shot). It’s very fluid, moving between the girls in a way that I don’t always see from H!P PVs. It adds a lot to the PV and is something I appreciate.

tokai4

 

Another thing I like is the set. I’m not sure where it is or if H!P built it, but the white serves a nice contrast to the girls, and all the stairs, mirrors and windows make for a much more interesting set than we’re used to.

tokai5

 

The effects add a nice burst of color to the plain white surroundings, and make it look interesting. Yet the effects never look tacky or just plain awful. They add a lot to making the PV look great.

tokai6

 

The dance shot is the worst part of the PV, by far. While C-ute does well with dancing, like always, I just don’t get some of the choices made. Could they have chosen a more boring place for their dance shot? Even if they rented this place out, surely they could have picked a better pace than a boring white wall. It just doesn’t fit with the reset of the great set.

tokai7

 

Compare this Airi…

tokai8

 

To this Airi. Notice anything? The answer is the lighting changed! Most of the PV has nice lighting. H!P PVs often have iffy lighting at best, so I was really excited to see how good the lighting looked until I saw the dance shot. Everything looks so drab, dark and flat in the dance shot that not even the visual effects can brighten it up. I would have probably not cared that much with this lighting had the rest of the PV not been lit well. Worse than being bad, it’s inconsistent.

Overall, Tokai no Hitorigurashi is a solid song/PV from C-ute. It has its share of issues, but is more than passable and even steps things up from an average Hello!Project release.

Ai tte Motto Zanshin

Song: This has the opposite issue to me than Tokai no Hitorigurashi; the chorus here isn’t what works. Up until the chorus I really enjoy this song a lot. It’s a cool song with a bit of a darker tone and utilizes some deeper vocals than I’m used to with C-ute. The instrumental sounds fitting and I don’t wish for a different arrangement like I do with Tokai no Hitorigurashi. However, everything I like about the song disappears with the chorus. It’s not a bad chorus, per say, but it has a very different feeling. The verses have a lot of oomph to them, for lack of a better term. The chorus sounds a lot happier and lighter, which feels wrong with the rest of the song.

The arrangement also falls flat in the chorus in that it feels empty. There’s a lot going on in the rest of the song, but it feels like most of that drops out for the substandard chorus.

I really like the heavy, dark feel of the song, and if the chorus could harness more of that I would be totally on board. However, the chorus alone keeps me from really feeling like this is an outstanding song. Which is a shame.

PV: Speaking of lighting…

aitte1

 

I love it. Seriously, H!P, keep this lighting designer please. This isn’t inconsistent, but just good. It plays a lot with light and shadow, all the while making sure that all the girls look good.

aitte2

 

Occasionally the girls are slightly overlit (one of my H!P PV pet peeves) BUT this is almost always a temporary thing and done for effect. But seriously, H!P, this is how you light a PV. This PV always looks gorgeous and visually interesting, even though it’s mostly just close-ups and dance shots. Despite the simplicity, the basic elements are done well, which means that I’ll want to watch this over most H!P PVs.

aitte3

 

Location wise… Dirty, falling apart warehouse? It’s not my first choice for a great PV location, but it this type of situation facilitated the lighting then I’m all for it. Plus it really goes well with the feel of most of the song.

aitte4

 

This PV also has a really nice sense of movement to it. The camera is rarely stationary, moving well with the C-ute members and aiding in the transitions. This makes for another fluid PV that doesn’t feel choppy. The best part is again at the beginning and whenever the girls do solo dances. The camera work and the editing work well together.

aitte5

 

The worst part of the PV are the cheap filters that are put on things. It doesn’t happen often enough that it feels like a proper part to the PV, like the effects in Tokai no Hitorigurashi. It just looks cheap and unnecessary.

The other negative is that it is a fairly simple PV. It’s comprised of the group dance shots, solo dance shots, solo closeups and some brief group closeups. I know that I said it’s done well enough that it makes it better, which is true. I love the lighting in this enough to make this one of my favorite C-ute PVs. However, just a bit more would make this PV really special.

Overall: Much like Tokai no Hitorigurashi, a few shortcomings make Ai tte Motto Zanshin fall a bit short of its potential. A lot of good things are there in the song and PV, but the issues keep it from being as good it can be.

This is a solid C-ute single and a solid H!P single. There are a lot of things I like, but enough frustrating things that make me wish that it had been done just a bit better.