Idol Thoughts: End of Year Reflections

Since Ray took a look at one of my posts, I’m going to respond to his!

The end of the year is coming up, and I’m starting to work on my end of 2013 lists for Happy Disco (best songs and best PVs) as well as thinking about what I want to write for Idolminded. I like a lot of idols and I’m interested in more than I like, so I have my work cut out for me.

There are a lot of difficult decisions to make, based essentially on how I want to run my blog and how I want to present myself on Idolminded. Here on Happy Disco, I feel comfortable being more biased. And while Idolminded isn’t supposed to be objective, I still feel like the end of the year posts are supposed to be a culmination of the idol world. Team Syachihoko at the top of every category doesn’t cut it.

This leads me to think about how I write all my lists here. While I do think I feel comfortable being biased on Happy Disco, in reality I do think about how I want to do lists a lot, especially with rankings. For example, I try to avoid duplicate groups on one list. Yet, I generally try to hold back and make mixed up, interesting lists.

It’s also divided between ‘favorite’ and ‘best.’ These can be totally different things, but a lot of people take them to mean the same thing. Essentially, a song could be my favorite, but I could view another as the best. Is Happy Disco aiming for a “favorite” or “best” model? It’s a tough call. This even brings up the question as to determining what is really the best, and if it’s possible to be at all objective about this sort of thing.

These lists are also interesting in that it puts idols against idols in ways you don’t really see. How do I compare a Babymetal song with an NMB48 song? This reminds me a bit of the current awards show races and best of the year results for movies and TV. How do you compare a comedy and a drama? I notice that dramas almost always get picked ahead of comedies. How possible is it to compare certain idol groups, if they very much are different.

Really, I think I tend to try to go a middle route between best and favorite; I throw in stuff I find legitimately interesting, but it wouldn’t be on a list if it wasn’t my favorite (as well as one of the best).

What do you think? Leave a comment and you too can be featured in next week’s Your Thoughts post!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *