Idol Thoughts: Idols in America

This is the first of my new series, idol thoughts, where every Wednesday I write something I’ve thought of recently and I invite guest responses! So please comment and I’ll include it in next week’s post.

A while back I was alerted to the new project by former *NSYNC member J.C. Chasez, Girl Radical. This is a currently 12 member girl group that he’s said was inspired by AKB48; on their official website it even states that it’s “Inspired by the trend of giant girl groups in Japan.” So it’s fair to say that, even if this isn’t the words that he’s directly used, that this is trying to be an idol project in the US.

Needless to say I’ve been intrigued. KPop has had an interesting relationship with the US (what with everyone thinking it was the next big thing and that just not happening yet), but JPop isn’t something that’s been attempted. I was actually a big *NSYNC fan back in the day, but girl groups have rarely had much pull in the US. Sure there were the Spice Girls, but they were a British group and one. I personally was a big fan of the girl group B*Witched (OK did I like asterisks or what?) but how many people actually remember them? Female pop stars are still really huge in the US, but is there room for girl groups? I’ve only seen skepticism for this group.

As an idol group, I actually think they’re doing a pretty good job of emphasizing personality. All the members have twitter accounts, there’s a Facebook page, and there’s a youtube channel where they’ve done some webisodes to try and show some of the members’ personality. This basically feels like a Japanese indie idol group would; they don’t have a TV show (and really, I doubt any American music act is going to get a show like AKBingo, since variety TV isn’t a big thing in the US). They don’t have much up yet, but I think it would be good if they kept it up.

Really, the biggest thing they absolutely need right now is some radio time and a good song. They only have a cover of No Doubt’s Just a Girl on their Youtube (as a No Doubt fan as well, I’m really surprised at how many of my interests converge here). Some news outlets are starting to write a little about this group, but until they have a big, popular song I don’t think people will much care about this group.

I’m a bit pleasantly surprised by what I’ve seen so far, but I still don’t know how the idol concept will translate to the US, if at all. I’d like to support more girl groups in the US, but I’m really not sure if they’re going to take off.

What do you think? Do you think girl groups could take off in the US? Could a group based on AKB48 in the US be popular? Should this even be attempted? Comment below!

One thought on “Idol Thoughts: Idols in America”

  1. OMG I still have that B*Witched CD! That is awesome! Girl Radical kind of sounds like an R & B version of FAKY to me. The makeup of the group also really looks like a group that Japanese fans envisioned an American AKB looking like. I hope it takes off, but I’m not overly optimistic about it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *