What Will I Do Without Meetan in AKB?

10
chuo1

I am in a quandary…

With Ohori Megumi’s move full time to SDN48, that leaves me without a favorite member of AKB48.  That is if you think of SDN as a totally separate group, like SKE.  So with the upcoming AKB shuffles to completely new teams, the “graduation” of 5 members to SDN and the promotion of quite a few Kenkyuusei it is time for me to think about which member I am going to support.  And to be honest, I am not sure who to pick.

So that means it’s time for nominations.  I went through the new teams and picked ten members I would consider to be among my favorites., Beginning with the new Team A…

Iwasa Misaki


Status: rising fast, has a great chance to become “my girl”
Argument for: She has been adorable every time I have seen her.  And I loved that she noticed me cheering at Webster Hall last week.  I hope she finds her niche in Team A.  It would be fun to support her from her humble beginnings!
Argument against: She is too new to get a true gauge of her talent.  And being with the heavyweights of Team A will make it tough for her to shine.  Oh, and she is only 14  (dangerous territory for me)

Maeda Atsuko


Status: Holds steady in my top 10.  She’s a safe pick, and I have always liked her
Argument for: For one, she’s adorable!  And there is no shortage of merchandise to collect.  I also like the idea of defending her among all of her detractors
Argument against: I would become a statistic, just one in a sea of Atsuko fans competing for her attention.  She is also a little too perfect…the perfect AkiP soldier.  She always answers questions in the way you would think the management wants her to answer.

Kojima Haruna


Status:  Rises a little after giving me a “special” autograph at NYAF.  “Hi Riku!”
Argument for: She is a total airhead, which makes her easy to laugh at.  She was brilliant in Mendol, and I love her in No3b.  She has a great “girl next door” quality.  The fact that she is a “girl-wota” is pretty cool too!
Argument against: Sometimes she comes across as aloof, and it makes me wonder if it is all an act or is she really just dopey?  As pretty as she is, sometimes she comes across as plain.  And she is often absent at the theater, so I hardly ever get to see her 🙁

Katayama Haruka


Status: Falls a little since I haven’t seen much of her lately
Argument for: She is a great singer!!!  One of the best in all of AKB.  She gets put into the best Team B sub-units, and she fills in really well on other teams.  I saw her do a show woth Team K, and she was awesome in it!
Argument against: Since management still hasn’t fully utilized her talent, we don’t get to see her enough.  I still haven’t seen any quirks on her, and quirkiness goes a long way in my book.

On paper, Team K might be my least favorite out of the gate.  Keep in mind that my opinions may change after seeing the new Teams in action.  But even if I like a lot of their members, there are few I really adore…

Akimoto Sayaka


Status: Rising a hell of a lot after seeing her at NYAF.
Argument for: I really got a chance to see how awesome she was at NYAF.  It all started at the autograph session.  She was by far the most gracious and authentic when she met the fans.  Just a totally nice girl.  And then there was Webster Hall, where she totally stole the show.  She ran the MC’s, was fierce in every song.  She completely put her heart into the New York event, and it showed.  Oh, and Mushi no BALLAD is friggin’ great!
Argument against: I still see her as more of a “girl’s idol”  She is all about female power.  While I appreciate that, it’s not what I look for in my favorite idol.  And with Ange and Heiwa’s awesome blog, I feel I would be horning in on their territory.

Tanabe Miku


Status: Falling fast.  She was once my second fave, but I am starting to lose hope.
Argument for: She is unique among her peers.  She has a beautiful dancer’s physique, and she looks much older than she actually is.  She pulls off “rocker chick” quite well, and in some of her pics she looks absolutely beautiful.
Argument against: PLEASE let your hair grow out again!  I think her short hairdo makes her look gangly, and for some reason a lot of the performance outfits don’t fit her well.  As much as her tall and muscular appearance makes her stand out she is still fairly shy during MC’s.  I would love to see her losen up and get goofy!

And that’s it for Team K, only 2 🙁
I still think Team A has the best “star power”, but Team B has the deepest roster.  There are about seven members of Team B I considered for this list.  It was tough to leave people off…

Kasai Tomomi


Status: Will always be one of my faves
Argument for: Chiyuuuuu!!!  She is soooooooo cute.  And she is very clever.  Tomomi plays the “lolli” card perfectly.  She doesn’t take herself seriously and always seems to be having fun.  She turns 18 pretty soon, so that makes her legal too.  I can’t look at her without thinking “kawaii!!!”
Argument against: I can’t really articulate an argument against her, but for some reason I don’t want to make her the easy winner.  Maybe it is because I’m afraid I will tire of her “act”.  I don’t know.  But she is one of the favorites.

Miyazaki Miho


Status: Rises after NYAF.  She really seemed to be trying to get my attention.
Argument for: She is hellaciously funny.  But behind that facade you can sort of see her insecurity.  She knows there are more popular girls around her, and she is hungry for attention.  She has one of the cutest catchphrases.  And after the way she played with me at NYAF it made me want to root for her
Argument against: She is still childlike in many ways.  I think she needs a couple more years to mature within the group.  And I hate to say it, but there are a lot of girls in AKB I find more attractive.

Kashiwagi Yuki


Status: Rises every time she appears in a photospread
Argument for: I love her look, especially in a bikini.  She has a young girls’ face on a woman’s body.  She still maintains a “lolli” image despite turning 18, and she is a pretty good singer.
Argument against: Looks only get you so far.  Like Haachan, she is lacking in the quirkiness department.  I would love to see her be the butt of a joke on AKBingo!, although her fondness for hot & spicy food on Shukan AKB was a plus!

Ishida Haruka


Status: I really like her, although to be honest she doesn’t have much of a chance to win here
Argument for: I appreciate her hard work as a Kenkyuusei.  It seems like she is in every single show either as a sub or backup dancer.  She isn’t the prettiest member, but she totally cute on stage.  I love when she teases her hair and makes it “big” on her head.  She has a natural underdog quality that makes me want to root for her.  And her AKB/BLT anniversary T-shirt is the best of the bunch!
Argument against: She still seems a bit timid on stage, and she hasn’t done much on AKBingo! despite having appeared on the show a few times.  I would love to see her get “bigger than life”…like her hair sometimes gets!

Anyway, thanks for letting me articulate all of this on paper.  After writing this I have narrowed it down to 3-4 members.  Hopefully I will decide before I get to Japan this month, as you always have to be ready for the inevitable question “Who do you support?”

I better have an answer!


CK in California
(credit to Stage48, especially takamina and afro stud for the pics)


10 thoughts on “What Will I Do Without Meetan in AKB?”

  1. if you choose kasai tomomi I’m disowning you, seriously. ANYONE BUT HER. the girl just creeps me out so much >_> from your list, I’d say Kashiwagi FTW FTW FTW but I’m personally an Erepyon supporter 😀 …which is weird because I’ve only listened to a few AKB singles but I still have a favorite? XD

  2. heh, I knew I wasn’t the only Meetan fan looking for a new AKB oshimen xD Even though, I’ll still support her no matter what, but I also consider AKB and SDN as two different groups, so that’s why. Also life as an AKB fan is pretty boring without having a girl to support and write letters to.

    btw I picked Mariya Suzuki (former 2nd-3rd favourite).

  3. Thanks for the advice all…

    @Valerie: Yes, Meetan will always be my favorite girl (just like I still adore Oh-yay) And it’s tough to find someone with a personality like Ohori. She is really one of a kind!

    @Amy: Uh oh…that doesn’t bode well for Tomo-mi. I don’t want to be disowned! Although I don’t think Yukirin makes my short-short list.

    @Sangackt: errr, Haachan solo stuff? I dunno? I just know her from the DVD’s, and her performances I have seen in person.

    Tough decisions!

  4. Whoa, you still don’t want to make Tomo~mi an easy winner? With all her creamy sweetness, sugar voice, and strawberry personality? You must be a cold hearted person 😆
    Good luck on finding your new oshimen!

    (But you see, Tomo~mi is an associate with Meetan in a lot of ways and many people said that now she “inherited” the sexy lady position from Meetan so… *evil laughs*)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *