Daisokaku Matsuri…It’s Called an Opportunity
How come every time there is a major AKB48 event I become more disillusioned with the overseas fandom? I see the stuff being written on forums and twitter…and I just shake my head in disbelief. It is either over-emotional reactionary nonsense. Declarations of failure before the proverbial paint is even dry, or (my favorite) the evil management posts. BTW, I am convinced the “blame management for everything” comments are merely the fallback when someone has nothing intelligent to say at all. It isn’t exclusive to overseas idol fans, there are plenty of moronic fans in Japan. But it just seems more prevalent among the fans who are not experiencing the fandom firsthand. All of that has compelled me to write my first post in a long time that isn’t a trip report. Yes, prescribing to the old saying that opinions are like assholes, I have one about the AKB48G Shuffle Event as well. It is written as a response to what I have been reading around the interwebs…
Every change made in the shuffle last night has the potential to be successful. Sure, some of these changes will turn out to be bigger successes than others. Some of them might even fail. But I don’t think anyone can realistically say “No, that absolutely will not work” with any type of real authority. I am endlessly amused at the people who think they can make those conclusions at this point in the game. So many “fans” immediately pull the ole’ “this is awful” and “greedy management” cards whenever there is any change. I’m beginning to wonder if some of them have Tourette’s. Or maybe they just get off on complaining, Anyway, the following is why I don’t have a problem with any of what was revealed last night at Diver City.
TRANSFERS
It seems to me that almost every member who transferred out of AKB was growing stagnant in the group. I mean were Sato Sumire, Chikano Rina, Kikuchi Ayaka, Ichikawa Miori, Fujie Reina, Yamauchi Suzuran or Oba Mina making strides toward senbatsu stardom? Or were they merely mid-back row performers for AKB? To me they are all in a potentially better place. Ota Aika comes to mind. She was no worse off than any of these members when she transferred to HKT. I think it has proven to be a good move for her.Umeda Ayaka ranks high undergirls, but that’s the only time she ever gets a whiff of senbatsu. Not to mention, she is 25 years old. Her transfer is a little harder to justify. But you never know, maybe Umechan decided that she wanted to live in Osaka for a year before she graduated.Iwata Karen is still in growth mode, but many of her peers get pushed much more than she does. There are newer gen. breathing down her back. And perhaps she was merely interested in a transfer. Same with Takashima. Far down the pecking order even in her own gen. Looking for a better opportunity in SKE. Maybe?
Maachun and Yuria’s transfers were definitely fueled by their own ambitions. And the same might be said about Tani and Chori. They are thick as theives, and they may have collectively decided that they didn’t want to continue to take a back seat to the HKT lolis. They also could very well may have Tokyo aspirations. From what we have seen of Tani’s diary I wouldn’t be surprised at all. I would have loved to see Marika make it all the way to AKB. But Nagoya gets her close, and there is always next year
KENNIN
2) When you have the Shinkansen in your country, the issue of traveling between cities is not really a major issue at all. I think a lot of people make too big a deal out of the commutes. Granted, I will give you that Fukuoka to Tokyo can be a bit of a trek by train. But it is a short flight. Most of the Kennin girls going to AKB find themelves in Tokyo for outside work anyway. And it isn’t like any of these members are leading the pack in theater appearances. So the “overworked” bit has become cliche by now.
3) I hear a lot of people worried about Captains holding concurrent positions. But it is common in business for people in leadership positions do extracurricular activities in their fields, and it doesn’t have to have a negative effect on their leadership in their primary job. Why would this be any different? I fail to see how girls like Sayanee and Nana heading out of town a few times a month for performances will negatively affect their ability to Captain their teams. Might be little harder for Sae, depending on how much time she is actually spending in China.
Speaking of Miyazawa Sae. I personally figured her next big move would be to graduate. But if she is going to avail her leadership skills to the members of SKE, I am all for it. If the SKE faithful have a problem with it, they will get over it. It is the SKE-fan M.O.
As for the members who are holding Kennin positions that don’t involve Akihabara (like Takayanagi Akane, Yamada Nana, Kimoto Kanon, Watanabe Miyuki) It is a bit harder to rationalize, but at least they are expanding their fanbase. It also serves as a sort of tryout for a future permanent transfer. Or maybe some of these members merely wanted to try something different. What I am saying is that it’s a bit simplistic to declare there is no benefit at all for the member. You don’t know what the motivation really was.
I don’t want to speak too much on Nogizaka46 since I don’t follow them. But there is definite potential benefit of increased interest for Ikoma Rina and the Nogizaka group itself. I think she is charming, and has a good chance to increase her fanbase with AKB. On the contrary, I don’t see how Matsui Rena benefits. But that could have been a bit of shrewd bargaining done by Sony. “You want to loan out one of our members? Which senbatsu member you gonna give us?”
All that said, I do agree that management needs to step up their game when utilizing the concurrent members. Not only within the theater, but the opportunities they avail themselves to outside.
CAPTAINS
I like the girls chosen as captains. I don’t see any girl who wasn’t deserving of the opportunity. Nakamura Mariko has certainly shown leadership skills as of late.As for Takamina, I don’t see her bing Captain of A as a step down at all. She is still the GM, right? In fact, I always found it silly that she was leader over all the teams but not the leader of her own team. To me it is a sign that she is still primarily interested in performing, as opposed to strictly being part of management.As for Nakanishi Yuka, it is too bad there is such a log jam in SKE’s management office as I think she would have been perfect for the SKE GM position ala Takamina and Sasshi. Nobody saw it as a demotion when Yukirin, Sayaka and Takamina lost their captainship last year. Why would this be any different?
And Matsumura Kaori as Queen of all Kenkyuusei is pure genius. I’m sure she is loving this appointment.
OVERALL TEAMS
Speaking of Team K. It isn’t lost on me that most of it’s star power derives from the concurrent members. But as a Wasamin fan, I see that as an opportunity. Finally most of the HKT48 fans can breathe easy (for the moment) because they didn’t mess too much with their recent shuffle.
I don’t want get into individual members. But as for the Paruru/Mayuyu thing, I think it is a case of much ado about nothing. They put them on their respective teams because they felt that was where they fit best. And until I see this mythical rulebook people keep quoting from that says Centers have to be from Team A (as well as other incredible “rules” I am always astounded to read ), I am going to cast it off as nonsense. I think the entire “who’s the next center” conversation is completely inappropriate at this point in time anyway. There are more important issues at hand.
The event had most everyone glued to their computers, jammed into movie theaters, and commentating all day on social media. So the way I see it the event was already a success. Fans have cried wolf about this stuff too many times. Most of the reactionary garbage doesn’t phase AkiP anymore.
Personally I would love for THIS to become an annual event. AKB48 is so murcurial. What works today, may not be so effective a year later. So to me it would be great to see them continue to make periodic evaluations and adjustments. Otherwise it just gets boring.
Just like the endless commentary “They are just doing it for the money, waaah
”
You mean the business is trying to increase profitability? How awful of them! ![]()
CK in California


